The Texas Court of Appeals has ruled against Dr. Andrew DuPont in a medical negligence case, affecting the ongoing legal battle between him and Willie Hawkins. The court's decision emphasizes the importance of timely serving expert reports in healthcare liability claims.
The case, Andrew DuPont, M.D. v. Willie Hawkins, was filed in the Texas Court of Appeals, 1st District under docket number 01-25-00890-CV. The court issued its opinion on November 10, 2026, after reviewing an interlocutory appeal from the trial court's order that denied Dr. DuPont's motion to dismiss Hawkins's claim for lack of an expert report.
Willie Hawkins, the plaintiff, accused Dr. DuPont of medical negligence after an endoscopic procedure where he allegedly left an old stomach tube inside Hawkins's body. Under the Texas Medical Liability Act (TMLA), Hawkins was required to serve Dr. DuPont with an expert report within 120 days after Dr. DuPont filed his original answer. However, Hawkins did not serve the report by the deadline, leading Dr. DuPont to seek dismissal of the case.
Hawkins claimed that he had prepared the expert report within the required timeframe but failed to serve it due to a technical issue with the electronic filing system. He argued that the trial court should view this as a curable deficiency rather than a total failure to serve. The trial court initially sided with Hawkins, denying Dr. DuPont's motion to dismiss.
The Texas Court of Appeals, however, disagreed with the trial court's ruling. The court held that Hawkins's failure to serve the expert report by the statutory deadline required dismissal of his claim against Dr. DuPont. The court stated, "Hawkins’s failure to serve an expert report by the statutory deadline mandates dismissal of his claim against Dr. DuPont. We reverse and render."
The ruling was made by a panel consisting of Justices Caughey, Morgan, and Dokupil. The court emphasized that strict compliance with the TMLA's service of expert reports is mandatory and that the trial court had no discretion to deny dismissal when no report was served.
In its analysis, the court clarified that the TMLA allows for extensions of the deadline only under specific circumstances, such as a written agreement between the parties or a single 30-day extension to cure a deficient report. The court noted that Hawkins's explanation of a technical glitch did not excuse his failure to meet the service requirement.
The court pointed out that the TMLA does not consider a claimant's good faith effort, mistakes, or lack of prejudice to the defendant when determining whether to dismiss a claim for failure to serve an expert report. The opinion referenced previous cases that reinforced the idea that the burden lies with the claimant to ensure compliance with the service requirement.
This ruling has significant implications for future medical negligence claims in Texas. It underscores the necessity for plaintiffs to adhere strictly to the TMLA's requirements regarding expert reports. Failure to do so can result in the dismissal of their claims, regardless of the circumstances surrounding the missed deadline.
Going forward, this decision serves as a reminder to all parties involved in healthcare liability claims to be vigilant about filing and serving expert reports on time. It also highlights the importance of understanding the legal requirements under the TMLA to avoid potential pitfalls that could jeopardize their cases.
As for what’s next, it is unclear whether Hawkins will seek to appeal this decision to a higher court. The court filing did not provide details on any related cases pending or if further legal action is expected from Hawkins.
Read Next
Texas Court affirms Shell's decision on employee bonuses
Texas Court upholds murder conviction of Rafael Arredondo
Texas court upholds constitutionality of sexual abuse statute
Court affirms denial of arbitration in Schelenz v. Miller
Court affirms ruling in medical malpractice arbitration case
Court affirms verdict in O'Connor v. American Medical Response










