The Ohio Court of Appeals has upheld a lower court's decision to terminate the parental rights of Crystal Ables, affecting her three children, R.A., H.A., and E.A. The ruling, made on June 25, 2026, emphasizes the children's best interests amid concerns over their safety and well-being.
The case, filed under docket numbers 2026-P-0021, 2026-P-0022, and 2026-P-0023, involved allegations of abuse and neglect against Ables and her partner, Robert Eiben. The Portage County Department of Job and Family Services (PCJFS) initially removed the children from their parents' custody on May 25, 2023, due to unsafe living conditions and a history of domestic violence. The court's decision to terminate parental rights highlights the importance of stable and secure environments for children.
Crystal Ables and Robert Eiben are the natural parents of R.A., born October 7, 2015, H.A., born May 10, 2018, and E.A., born August 20, 2020. The children were placed in temporary custody of PCJFS shortly after their removal. The agency filed complaints alleging that the children were abused, neglected, or dependent. The trial court adjudicated the children as dependent on June 30, 2023, and established a case plan for the parents to follow.
The case plan required both parents to complete various assessments and counseling, secure stable housing, and engage in family counseling. Despite some initial progress, the parents ultimately failed to meet the requirements of the case plan. The court noted that the children had been in PCJFS custody for more than 12 of the preceding 22 months, which met the statutory criteria for permanent custody.
During the hearings, evidence presented showed that the living conditions in the parents' residence were cluttered and unsanitary. Witnesses testified that the children thrived in their foster homes, receiving proper care and support. The court also heard testimony regarding the parents' ongoing issues, including domestic violence, substance abuse, and an unstable living environment.
In its ruling, the court stated, "The evidence at the permanent custody hearing supports the trial court’s judgment entry granting the Portage County Department of Job and Family Services permanent custody of the children." Judge John Eklund emphasized that the parents had not sufficiently remedied the conditions that led to the children's removal. The court found that the children's best interests would be served by granting permanent custody to PCJFS.
The ruling carries significant implications for families involved in similar cases. It reinforces the importance of meeting case plan requirements and the need for parents to demonstrate a commitment to providing a safe and nurturing environment for their children. The decision also highlights the court's responsibility to prioritize children's welfare in custody matters.
As for what lies ahead, it is unclear whether Ables or Eiben will appeal the court's decision. The court's ruling may set a precedent for future cases involving parental rights and the factors considered in determining the best interests of children. The court filing did not provide details on any related cases pending or potential appeals.