In a recent ruling, the Court of Appeals of Washington affirmed a lower court's decision that found Stanton Bernhart Limited Partnership and its affiliates liable for trespass and nuisance due to the diversion of water onto Robert Shawn Noecker's properties. The court's decision, filed under docket number 87820-4, also remanded the case to consider emotional distress damages for Noecker, which were previously denied.

This case is significant as it addresses property rights and the responsibilities of landowners regarding water management. The ruling impacts Noecker, who has faced ongoing damage to his properties due to the actions of Bernhart, and sets a precedent for similar disputes involving water flow and property damage.

Background

The dispute began when Stanton Bernhart purchased a parcel of land in Bothell, Washington, in 2003. Robert Noecker acquired adjacent properties in 2006 and 2012, where he built a home and a shop. The Bernhart property is located uphill from Noecker's properties, which became the focal point of the legal conflict.

The issues arose from a dam built in 1981 on the Bernhart property, which was intended to manage water flow. However, after Bernhart conducted unauthorized repairs on the dam in 2017, it failed, leading to significant water and sediment runoff onto Noecker's properties. Noecker claimed that this runoff caused extensive damage, including the filling of ponds on his land.

Noecker filed a lawsuit against Bernhart, asserting claims of trespass, negligence, and nuisance. The case proceeded to a bench trial in August 2024, where the court heard testimony and examined evidence regarding the impact of Bernhart's actions.

The Ruling

The court ruled in favor of Noecker, concluding that Bernhart's actions constituted trespass and nuisance. The judge noted that the diversion of water from Bernhart’s property to Noecker’s properties was intentional and caused substantial damages. The court stated, "The excess water and sediment caused by the ditch work are a continuing trespass because they constitute an invasion of the North Noecker Property that affects Noecker’s interest in exclusive possession."

The court also found that the work done on the dam was inadequate and did not meet industry standards, leading to further damage to Noecker's properties. The trial court awarded Noecker $554,294.35 for trespass and nuisance, along with additional costs and attorney fees. However, the court denied Noecker's request for emotional distress damages, stating that the claims did not support such an award.

Impact

This ruling is significant as it reinforces the legal principle that landowners are responsible for managing water flow on their properties to prevent harm to neighboring properties. The court's decision to affirm the lower court's findings emphasizes the importance of adhering to environmental regulations and obtaining necessary permits for construction and repair work.

The remand for consideration of emotional distress damages could set a precedent for future cases where property damage leads to psychological harm. This aspect of the ruling highlights the courts' recognition of the emotional toll that property disputes can take on individuals.

What's Next

The case may be appealed further, but the ruling currently stands. The court will now consider Noecker's claim for emotional distress damages in a subsequent hearing. This aspect of the case remains unresolved, and the outcome could influence how similar claims are handled in the future.