The Washington Court of Appeals has affirmed the 18-year prison sentence of Leland Dulani Harris, who pleaded guilty to attempted second-degree murder for trying to stab his ex-girlfriend in 2013. The court ruled that Harris's appeal for resentencing, based on a miscalculated offender score, was without merit. This decision affects Harris, his family, and the legal standards surrounding sentencing in cases involving domestic violence.

The case, State of Washington v. Leland Dulani Harris, No. 87523-0-I, stems from a violent incident in which Harris attempted to stab his ex-girlfriend, Carmen Young, while their two minor children were present. The court's ruling emphasizes the seriousness of domestic violence and the considerations involved in sentencing such crimes.

Background

Leland Harris and Carmen Young had a tumultuous relationship marked by domestic violence. In 2013, after being released from prison, Harris traveled to Washington to visit Young and their two children. During his visit, he attacked Young, stabbing her multiple times while their children were nearby. Following this incident, Harris was charged with attempted second-degree murder and other related offenses.

In 2014, Harris pleaded guilty to the attempted murder charge, stipulating to an aggravating factor that the crime occurred in the presence of their minor children. The court initially calculated Harris's offender score based on a prior conviction, which later became a point of contention in his appeal. The sentencing court imposed an exceptional sentence of 18 years, reasoning that this would ensure Harris remained incarcerated until the children reached adulthood.

The Ruling

In the recent ruling, the Court of Appeals upheld the trial court's decision to deny Harris's motion for resentencing under CrR 7.8(b). Harris argued that his offender score included an invalid out-of-state conviction following the Washington Supreme Court's decision in State v. Blake, which affected how certain offenses were classified under state law.

The court ruled, "Harris failed to establish that he was entitled to collateral relief under CrR 7.8(b)(5)." This means that the court found no basis for Harris's claim that the miscalculation of his offender score constituted a fundamental defect in his sentencing.

The judges noted that Harris's miscalculated offender score did not significantly impact his sentence, as the trial court had made it clear that the 18-year sentence was based on the nature of the crime and its impact on the children involved. The court emphasized that the sentencing judge's intent was to protect the children by ensuring Harris remained in prison until they became adults.

Impact

This ruling reinforces the importance of considering the context of violent crimes, especially those involving domestic violence and children. The court's decision indicates that even if there are errors in calculating an offender's score, the overall context and the judge's reasoning can uphold a sentence if it serves to protect victims and society.

The ruling may also set a precedent for future cases involving similar circumstances, where the presence of children during a violent crime may lead to harsher sentencing, regardless of minor discrepancies in the offender's score. This decision highlights the court's commitment to addressing the serious implications of domestic violence.

What's Next

Harris's options for further appeal appear limited following this ruling. While he could potentially seek review from the Washington Supreme Court, the court's decision to affirm the lower court's ruling suggests that his chances of success may be minimal. Details regarding any related cases or motions were not available in the court filing.