In a recent ruling, the Washington Court of Appeals upheld a previous court's decision in favor of Costco Wholesale Corporation in a negligence case brought by Heather Bradford. The case stems from an incident where Bradford was struck by a furniture box while shopping at a Costco store in Bellingham in 2018. The court's decision is significant as it reinforces the standards for negligence claims and the admissibility of expert testimony in trial settings.
The incident occurred on August 4, 2018, when Bradford was shopping at Costco. An employee was pulling a flatbed cart loaded with furniture boxes, and as they approached one another, a box fell and hit Bradford on the shoulder. Following the incident, Bradford reported experiencing chronic pain and subsequently filed a lawsuit against Costco in July 2021, claiming negligence for failing to maintain safe premises.
The case was brought before the Court of Appeals of Washington under docket number 89153-7 on November 16, 2026. The trial began on October 7, 2025, and during the proceedings, a jury found that neither Bradford nor Costco was negligent. Following the verdict, Bradford sought a new trial, citing several issues, including the admission of deposition testimony from an unavailable expert witness, the denial of a res ipsa loquitur instruction, and the complexity of the special verdict form presented to the jury.
In its ruling, the court addressed Bradford's arguments regarding the trial court's decisions. The court ruled that the trial court acted appropriately in allowing the admission of the deposition testimony of Dr. Michael Hatzakis, an expert witness who was unavailable due to being out of the country. The court noted, "This is appropriate to use portions of the deposition testimony under Civil Rule 32(a)(3)(e), that portion of the rule allows for extraordinary circumstances when presented to the court during the course of the trial to consider the use of deposition in lieu of live testimony." The court found that the circumstances surrounding Dr. Hatzakis's absence constituted extraordinary circumstances justifying the use of his deposition.
Furthermore, the court ruled that the refusal to give a res ipsa loquitur instruction was also appropriate. The court explained that both parties had presented evidence regarding the incident, which provided a clear understanding of how it occurred. The court stated, "Where the cause of an incident can be fully explained by the evidence, a res ipsa instruction is not required." This ruling indicates that the court believes that negligence must be proven with specific evidence rather than relying on presumptions.
The court also addressed Bradford's concerns regarding the special verdict form, which she argued was confusing. The court found that the form accurately reflected the questions that needed to be answered by the jury and was consistent with the requirements of civil procedure. The court noted that Bradford did not propose an alternative form, which further weakened her argument.
The impact of this ruling is significant for both consumers and businesses. It reinforces the importance of presenting clear evidence in negligence claims and clarifies the standards for admitting expert testimony in court. By affirming the trial court's decision, the Court of Appeals has set a precedent that may influence future negligence cases, particularly those involving expert witnesses and jury instructions.
Moving forward, this ruling may affect how parties approach the presentation of expert testimony in trials, especially when there are concerns about a witness's availability. It also emphasizes the need for clarity in jury instructions and special verdict forms to ensure that jurors can make informed decisions based on the evidence presented.
As of now, it remains unclear whether Bradford will seek to appeal the decision further. The court filing did not provide details on any potential next steps or related cases pending in connection with this ruling. However, the outcome serves as a reminder of the complexities involved in negligence cases and the importance of thorough preparation and presentation in court.
Read Next
Court upholds 14-day involuntary mental health commitment
Court affirms 14-day involuntary treatment for K.C.
Washington court rules on parentage in sexual assault case
Kentucky Court Rules on Workers' Compensation Case
Kansas Court upholds dismissal in medical malpractice case
California Court reverses ruling on arbitration in wage case










