The Tennessee Supreme Court ruled on November 2, 2026, regarding the Metropolitan Government of Nashville and Davidson County's challenge to a state law that imposed a cap on the size of metropolitan councils. This ruling affects Nashville's governance structure and the rights of local governments under the Tennessee Constitution.
The case, titled Metropolitan Government of Nashville and Davidson County v. Bill Lee, Governor, was prompted by a law passed by the General Assembly in 2023 that limited the size of metropolitan councils to twenty members. The Metropolitan Government, along with individual plaintiffs, argued that this cap violated the Local Legislation Clause and the Exemption Clause of the Tennessee Constitution. The trial court agreed with the plaintiffs, but the Court of Appeals reversed that decision, leading to the Supreme Court's involvement.
The Supreme Court's ruling concluded that the amendments made to the law after the appeal rendered the plaintiffs' Local Legislation Clause claim moot, meaning there was no longer a legal issue to resolve regarding that claim. However, the court maintained that the Exemption Clause claim was still valid and addressed it on its merits. The court affirmed the Court of Appeals' decision that the cap does not violate the Exemption Clause.
Background
The parties involved in this case include the Metropolitan Government of Nashville and Davidson County, represented by attorneys Wallace W. Dietz, Allison L. Bussell, and others, and the state officials, including Governor Bill Lee, represented by Attorney General Jonathan Skrmetti.
The dispute arose when the Tennessee General Assembly enacted House Bill No. 48 in March 2023, which imposed a cap on the size of metropolitan councils. At that time, Nashville's council had forty members. The law required that councils with more than twenty members reduce their size to comply with the new limit.
Metro Nashville filed a lawsuit against Governor Lee and other state officials shortly after the law was enacted, claiming that the cap violated various provisions of the Tennessee Constitution. The trial court initially sided with the Metropolitan Government, but the Court of Appeals later reversed that decision, prompting the Supreme Court's review.
The Ruling
The Tennessee Supreme Court ruled that the amendments made to House Bill No. 48 after the appeal rendered the plaintiffs' Local Legislation Clause claim moot. The court stated, "We conclude that those amendments render the plaintiffs’ Local Legislation Clause claim moot," indicating that the changes to the law eliminated the legal controversy regarding that claim.
However, the court affirmed the Court of Appeals' ruling that the cap does not violate the Exemption Clause of the Tennessee Constitution. Justice Sarah K. Campbell delivered the opinion of the court, joined by Chief Justice Jeffrey S. Bivins and Justices Holly Kirby, Dwight E. Tarwater, and Roger A. Page. Justice Mary L. Wagner did not participate in the decision.
Impact
This ruling has significant implications for local governance in Nashville and potentially sets a precedent for how state laws can affect metropolitan councils across Tennessee. By affirming that the cap does not violate the Exemption Clause, the court has upheld the state's authority to impose limits on local government structures.
The decision also clarifies the legal landscape regarding the balance of power between state government and local municipalities, particularly concerning legislative actions that affect local governance. It underscores the importance of constitutional provisions in protecting local government autonomy while also allowing for state oversight.
What's Next
The plaintiffs may consider their options for appeal regarding the Exemption Clause claim, but the court's ruling effectively upholds the cap on council size. There are no related cases pending that directly involve the same issues, but the ruling may influence future legislative actions and challenges regarding local governance in Tennessee.














