The Third Circuit Court of Appeals has denied a petition for rehearing filed by Holy Trinity Ukrainian Catholic Church in a case concerning zoning regulations imposed by Collier Township. The ruling, which was issued on November 16, 2026, affects the church's ability to construct a shrine on its property and highlights ongoing tensions between local governance and religious freedoms.
This case is significant as it raises questions about the balance between municipal regulations and the rights of religious organizations, particularly under the Religious Land Use and Institutionalized Persons Act (RLUIPA). The court's decision could influence how similar cases are handled in the future, especially in terms of the protections afforded to religious entities against local zoning laws.
Background
Holy Trinity Ukrainian Catholic Church, the appellant in this case, sought to build a shrine dedicated to St. Mary on its property in Collier Township, Pennsylvania. However, the township denied the church's rezoning application, claiming it did not meet local zoning requirements. This denial led the church to file a lawsuit against the township, arguing that the decision violated its rights under RLUIPA.
The case was initially heard in the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Pennsylvania, where the church sought a preliminary injunction to allow construction while the case was being litigated. The district court ruled against the church, leading to the appeal to the Third Circuit Court. The church argued that the township's actions imposed a substantial burden on its religious exercise, which is protected under federal law.
The Ruling
The Third Circuit Court ultimately denied the church's petition for rehearing, stating that a majority of the judges did not find sufficient grounds to reconsider the earlier ruling. The court's opinion noted that the church had not demonstrated that the township's actions constituted irreparable harm. The judges emphasized that the balance of interests favored the township's regulatory authority over the church's claims.
The court ruled, "The petition for rehearing by the panel and the Court en banc is DENIED." This indicates that the court did not find compelling reasons to revisit its previous decision.
Judge Phipps, joined by Judges Matey, Bove, and Mascott, filed a dissenting opinion, arguing that the majority's ruling could misinterpret the foundational principles of religious freedom in the United States. Judge Phipps contended that the denial of the church's application for a shrine likely imposed a substantial burden on its religious exercise, which should have warranted a preliminary injunction.
Impact
The denial of rehearing in this case has significant implications for religious organizations seeking to navigate local zoning laws. It underscores the challenges that churches and other religious entities face when attempting to expand or develop properties for religious purposes. The ruling may deter other religious organizations from pursuing similar zoning applications, fearing that they may not receive the necessary approvals from local authorities.
Furthermore, the dissenting opinion raises concerns about the potential erosion of religious freedoms in the face of municipal regulations. The dissenting judges emphasized that the majority's ruling could set a precedent that prioritizes local governance over federally protected rights, which could have broader implications for religious liberties across the country.
What's Next
While the Third Circuit has denied the petition for rehearing, the church may still explore other legal avenues, including a potential appeal to the U.S. Supreme Court. However, details regarding any such plans were not available in the court filing. The church's ongoing struggle with local zoning laws may continue to unfold in the courts, as similar cases arise across the nation.
Read Next
Court reinstates arbitration award for PPL Electric employee
Court upholds ruling in child pornography case against Anderson
Court denies David Lettieri's request for mandamus relief
Court upholds ruling in age discrimination case against school board
California Court of Appeal Reverses $27 Million Verdict
Court affirms dismissal of mother’s claims against DHS










