The Third Circuit Court of Appeals has upheld the 10-year sentence of Naquann Simmons, who pleaded guilty to aiding and abetting the making of false statements in the acquisition of firearms. This ruling, filed on November 16, 2026, affects Simmons and sets a precedent for how prior convictions are considered in sentencing for firearm-related offenses.
Simmons was convicted under 18 U.S.C. §§ 2, 922(a)(6), and 924(a)(2) for his role in the illegal acquisition of firearms. The court's decision is significant as it clarifies how prior criminal history can influence sentencing in similar cases, particularly regarding the classification of prior offenses.
Naquann Simmons faced charges after being involved in making false statements during the purchase of firearms. His case originated in the U.S. District Court for the Middle District of Pennsylvania, where he was sentenced by Judge Malachy E. Mannion. Simmons had a criminal history that included a second-degree harassment conviction from New York, which played a crucial role in determining his sentencing.
The dispute in this case arose from the calculation of Simmons's criminal history category. The District Court classified him as having a criminal history category of III, based on his previous convictions. This classification placed him in a sentencing range of 37 to 46 months. However, the court decided to impose an upward variance, resulting in a sentence of 120 months.
During the appeal, the court examined whether Simmons's prior harassment conviction should count towards his criminal history score. The court ruled that the New York second-degree harassment conviction was not similar to offenses excluded from receiving criminal history points, such as disorderly conduct or contempt of court. The opinion stated, "Simmons’s prior conviction is not 'similar to' an excluded offense under the Guidelines, and the District Court properly awarded criminal history points for the conviction."
The judges on the panel included Circuit Judges Shwartz, Montgomery-Reeves, and Rendell. They reviewed the case under the Guidelines and determined that the District Court's decision to include Simmons's prior harassment conviction in his criminal history was appropriate. The court noted that the elements of the harassment statute involved a specific intent to harass, which differentiated it from excluded offenses.
The court's opinion emphasized that even if there were a question about whether the harassment conviction was similar to excluded offenses, the District Court did not make a plain error in its judgment. The ruling stated, "Even if Simmons’s prior convictions were 'similar to' disorderly conduct, the District Court did not plainly err in counting his harassment offense toward his criminal history score." This affirmation means that Simmons's sentence will stand as imposed.
The implications of this ruling extend beyond Simmons. It clarifies how courts may interpret prior convictions when determining criminal history scores in future firearm-related cases. The decision reinforces the idea that certain convictions, even if they may seem minor, can significantly impact sentencing outcomes, particularly in firearm offenses.
Additionally, this ruling may influence similar cases where defendants have prior harassment convictions or other misdemeanors. The court's interpretation of what constitutes a similar offense under the Guidelines will likely guide future sentencing decisions.
Looking ahead, Simmons may still pursue further legal options, including a potential appeal to a higher court. However, the court did not indicate any immediate related cases pending that could affect the outcome of his situation. The legal landscape surrounding firearm offenses and prior convictions remains a critical area for defendants and legal practitioners alike.
Read Next
Court denies David Lettieri's request for mandamus relief
Court affirms ruling against Tracy Williams in fraud case
Court affirms dismissal of inmate's medical care lawsuit
Pennsylvania court upholds lengthy sentence for animal cruelty
Pennsylvania Court Upholds SVP Designation for Newman
Pennsylvania Court Affirms Life Sentence for Ali Marsh










