The Superior Court of Pennsylvania has ordered a new trial in a case involving Citibank and Caleb Ouedraogo concerning a disputed credit card debt. The court's decision, filed on November 16, 2026, comes after Ouedraogo appealed a previous judgment that favored Citibank. This ruling is significant as it highlights issues regarding evidence and due process in debt collection cases.
Caleb Ouedraogo opened a Citibank Costco credit card account in 2021. The account was managed by Citibank, and Ouedraogo made his last payment on April 7, 2023. Citibank later filed a complaint against him in February 2024, claiming he owed $6,444.99. Ouedraogo contested the debt, asserting he never entered into a contract with Citibank and did not receive the necessary statements regarding his account.
The case began when Citibank filed an initial complaint in February 2024. After arbitration ruled in favor of Citibank in December 2024, Ouedraogo appealed, leading to a trial set for December 2024. A pre-trial conference was scheduled for June 2025, but Citibank failed to appear, resulting in a judgment against them. Citibank later requested to have that judgment stricken, which the court granted. A bench trial occurred on October 29, 2025, where Ouedraogo represented himself, and Citibank was represented by attorney Michael Lipinski.
During the trial, Citibank presented documents but did not formally admit them as evidence. Ouedraogo denied having a Costco credit card and argued that the evidence presented was unauthenticated hearsay. The court ultimately ruled in favor of Citibank, awarding the claimed amount. Ouedraogo then filed a post-trial motion, arguing that the judgment was based on insufficient evidence and that the court relied on attorney arguments rather than proper testimony.
In its ruling, the court noted that the trial lacked proper evidence, stating, "The judgment was unsupported by record evidence." Judge Bowes, along with Judges Olson and McLaughlin, agreed that the trial court had abused its discretion by denying Ouedraogo's post-trial motion. The court emphasized that Citibank's documents were never admitted into evidence and that the trial did not meet the necessary standards for due process.
The ruling has important implications for debt collection cases, particularly regarding the need for proper evidence and the rights of defendants to challenge claims against them. It underscores the necessity for creditors to present authenticated evidence and for courts to ensure fair trials.
Looking ahead, the case will return to the lower court for a new trial, where both parties will have the opportunity to present their arguments and evidence again. This ruling may also influence similar cases where debt collection practices and evidence admissibility are in question. Ouedraogo's case highlights the complexities of debt disputes and the importance of procedural fairness in the judicial process.
As of now, there are no indications that this case will be appealed further, but it remains to be seen how the new trial will unfold and whether Citibank will adjust its approach in light of the court's findings.
Read Next
Pennsylvania court affirms life sentences for Eric Reid
Pennsylvania court upholds lengthy sentence for animal cruelty
Pennsylvania Court Upholds SVP Designation for Newman
Texas Court affirms Shell's decision on employee bonuses
Court dismisses POM of Pennsylvania's claims against PSP
Kansas Court Affirms Ruling Against Bellwethr for Tax Credit Breach










