On October 20, 2026, Arkansas Attorney General Tim Griffin issued an opinion regarding the release of employee records under the Arkansas Freedom of Information Act (FOIA). This opinion, identified as Opinion No. 2026-113, came in response to a request from Travis Harp, who objected to the release of his employment records by the City of Gravette. The ruling clarifies the standards for disclosing such records, which affect public employees and their privacy rights.

The dispute arose when the City of Gravette received a FOIA request for Harp's employment records. The records custodian indicated that the records were subject to release, with any necessary redactions. Harp contested this decision, prompting the Attorney General's office to evaluate whether the custodian's actions were consistent with the FOIA.

The FOIA allows individuals to request access to public records, and it is designed to promote transparency in government. However, it also includes provisions to protect personal privacy. In this case, Harp sought guidance on whether the custodian's decision to release his records complied with these privacy protections.

In his opinion, Griffin noted that he could not definitively determine the appropriateness of the custodian's decision without reviewing the actual records. He emphasized that the legal standards governing the disclosure of personnel and employee-evaluation records under the FOIA are complex. The opinion outlined that a document must be disclosed if it meets specific criteria, including being a public record and not falling under any exceptions that would allow withholding.

Griffin explained that personnel records are generally open to public inspection unless their disclosure would constitute a clearly unwarranted invasion of personal privacy. He referenced a balancing test established by the Arkansas Supreme Court in Young v. Rice, which weighs the public's interest in accessing the records against the individual's interest in keeping them private.

The court ruled, "the custodian must assess whether the information contained in the requested document is of a personal or intimate nature such that it gives rise to a greater than minimal privacy interest."

For employee-evaluation records, the opinion stated that such documents cannot be released unless certain conditions are met, including that the employee has been suspended or terminated, there has been a final administrative resolution, and the public has a compelling interest in the disclosure. Griffin noted that the primary purpose of this exception is to preserve the confidentiality of the formal job-evaluation process to encourage honest communication between employees and employers.

Griffin concluded that while the custodian had determined Harp's records were subject to release, he could not affirm this decision without reviewing the records themselves. He stated that the custodian's decisions regarding the release, redaction, or withholding of the records should be governed by the legal standards discussed in his opinion.

This opinion has significant implications for public employees in Arkansas. It clarifies the legal framework surrounding the disclosure of employment records and underscores the importance of balancing public access with personal privacy. The ruling may influence future FOIA requests and the handling of employee records by public entities.

Moving forward, public employees and officials must be aware of their rights and responsibilities under the FOIA. The opinion serves as a reminder that while transparency is vital, protecting individual privacy is equally important. The ruling may also prompt discussions about potential changes to FOIA regulations to better address privacy concerns.

As for next steps, it remains unclear whether Harp or the City of Gravette will appeal the Attorney General's opinion. The opinion does not mention any related cases pending, but it sets a precedent for how similar disputes might be handled in the future.