The Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania recently ruled in favor of Lynn Builders, LLC, allowing them to build a single-family home on an undersized lot in East Rockhill Township. This decision affects neighboring property owners Paul Hennessy and Beverly Girgenti, who opposed the variances granted by the East Rockhill Township Zoning Hearing Board (ZHB). The court's ruling clarifies the standards for granting zoning variances in cases involving nonconforming lots.
The case, Paul Hennessy and Beverly Girgenti v. East Rockhill Township ZHB, was filed under docket number 693 C.D. 2025. The court's decision, issued on November 16, 2026, confirmed the ZHB's earlier ruling that granted two variances to Lynn Builders, allowing them to construct a home on a lot that does not meet the minimum size and width requirements set by the township's zoning ordinance.
Background
The dispute centers around Lot 5, a heavily wooded property measuring approximately 0.861 acres with a width of 125 feet, located in a Rural Residential (RR) zoning district. The minimum required lot size in this district is 1.8 acres, and the minimum width is 150 feet. Lot 5 was created in 1969 as part of a two-lot subdivision but has never been developed.
Paul Hennessy and Beverly Girgenti, the neighboring property owners, appealed the ZHB's decision to grant variances that would allow Lynn Builders to build on Lot 5. They argued that the two lots, Lot 2 and Lot 5, had merged under the township's zoning ordinance, which would require the denial of the variances. The ZHB held public hearings where both sides presented their arguments, but ultimately, the ZHB found that the lots had not merged and that the variances were justified.
The Ruling
The Commonwealth Court, led by President Judge Renée Cohn Jubelirer, affirmed the ZHB's decision. The court found that the ZHB had properly granted the variances based on the evidence presented. The ruling stated, "The ZHB concluded that the conditions and circumstances of Lot 5 posed a hardship for Applicants that was not self-created, as Lot 5 was a lawful pre-existing nonconforming lot."
The court also noted that the ZHB's conclusion that the variances would not alter the essential character of the neighborhood was supported by substantial evidence. The ZHB had determined that the concerns raised by Hennessy and Girgenti were speculative and did not warrant denial of the variances.
Impact
This ruling has significant implications for property owners in East Rockhill Township and potentially sets a precedent for similar cases involving undersized lots. The court's affirmation of the ZHB's decision clarifies that neighboring property owners must provide substantial evidence to support claims of merger under zoning ordinances. The ruling reinforces the idea that variances can be granted when a property is a lawful pre-existing nonconforming lot and when the hardship is not self-created.
The decision may encourage other property owners with similar zoning challenges to seek variances, knowing that the courts may uphold such requests if the proper criteria are met. It also highlights the importance of thorough hearings and evidence presentation in zoning matters.
What's Next
While Hennessy and Girgenti can appeal the Commonwealth Court's decision to the Pennsylvania Supreme Court, it remains to be seen if they will pursue this option. The ruling may also influence future zoning cases in the area, particularly those involving nonconforming lots and the standards for granting variances.
Read Next
Court affirms denial of zoning variance for Wind Gap project
Court affirms arbitration ruling in PSU union dispute
Court Quashes Appeal by Clay Caldwell Over Timeliness Issues
New Jersey Tax Court dismisses property tax appeal case
Arizona Court affirms attorney fee award in divorce case
Arizona court rules on Nicholas Didur's civil rights appeal










