The Pennsylvania Commonwealth Court has ordered a review of a records request case involving Matthew Haverstick and Kleinbard LLC against the Pennsylvania Office of the Governor. The court's decision, issued on November 16, 2026, vacates a previous ruling by the Office of Open Records (OOR) that denied the requesters access to certain documents. This ruling is significant because it emphasizes the importance of transparency and accountability in government operations.
The case stems from a records request submitted by Haverstick and Kleinbard LLC on March 14, 2025. The request sought communications between the Office of General Counsel (OGC) and private casinos, as well as communications with the Pennsylvania State Police (PSP). While some records were provided, many were withheld, citing attorney-client privilege and the attorney-work-product doctrine. The OGC argued that these exemptions applied under the Right-to-Know Law (RTKL), which governs public access to government records.
Following the initial request, Haverstick and Kleinbard appealed to the OOR, seeking an evidentiary hearing to challenge the OGC's claims. The OOR directed the OGC to provide further justification for its refusal to disclose the records. However, the OOR ultimately denied the appeal on September 25, 2025, concluding that the withheld documents were protected under the claimed exemptions.
The case was then brought before the Commonwealth Court, where the judges reviewed the arguments presented by both parties. The court found that the OOR had erred in its decision, particularly regarding the application of the attorney-client privilege and the work-product doctrine. The court noted that the OGC had not sufficiently demonstrated that the withheld documents met the criteria for these exemptions.
The court ruled, "the Eisenstein affirmation is facially inadequate, conclusory, and otherwise generic." The judges emphasized that the OGC's failure to provide detailed information about the withheld documents undermined its claims for exemption.
Judges Stacy Wallace, Anne E. Covey, and Mary Hannah Leavitt presided over the case. The court's ruling vacated the OOR's final determination and remanded the matter for further proceedings, specifically instructing the OOR to conduct an in camera review of the withheld documents. This review will help determine whether the claimed privileges apply to the records in question.
This decision has significant implications for future records requests and government transparency in Pennsylvania. It reinforces the principle that government agencies must provide clear and detailed justifications when withholding documents from public access. The court's ruling also highlights the need for agencies to carefully assess their claims of privilege and ensure they are not using blanket assertions to deny access to potentially public information.
The outcome of this case may influence how other agencies handle similar requests under the RTKL. It serves as a reminder that transparency is a fundamental aspect of government accountability, and agencies must be prepared to substantiate their claims when denying access to records.
As for what’s next, the OOR is required to conduct the in camera review within 60 days of the court's order. This review will determine if the attorney-client privilege and work-product doctrine apply to the withheld documents. If the OOR finds that the exemptions do not apply, the records may be released to Haverstick and Kleinbard. There is no indication in the court filing that the decision can be appealed further.
Read Next
Court affirms denial of zoning variance for Wind Gap project
Court affirms arbitration ruling in PSU union dispute
Court Quashes Appeal by Clay Caldwell Over Timeliness Issues
New Jersey Tax Court dismisses property tax appeal case
Arizona Court affirms attorney fee award in divorce case
Arizona court rules on Nicholas Didur's civil rights appeal










