The Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania has upheld a decision by the Unemployment Compensation Board of Review (UCBR) that denied Shaniquia McCall's request to backdate her unemployment benefits claim. The court ruled on November 16, 2026, affirming the Board's earlier decision that McCall did not provide sufficient evidence to justify her request. This ruling affects McCall, who filed her claim for unemployment benefits in August 2022 but sought to backdate it to include a period from April to July of that year.
The case centers around McCall's application for unemployment benefits, which she initially filed on August 4, 2022. After facing issues with her claim being “locked,” she attempted to backdate her application to cover the period from April 9, 2022, to July 9, 2022. McCall claimed she was unable to file for those weeks due to the locked status of her account. However, her request to backdate was denied by the Pennsylvania Department of Labor and Industry on December 23, 2024, leading her to appeal the decision.
During a hearing on May 5, 2025, McCall testified that she had attempted to file her claims but was unable to do so. Despite her testimony, the Referee found that there was no evidence to support her claims of being locked out of her account prior to her request for backdating in December 2024. The Referee concluded that McCall was ineligible for backdating her claim, as the Department's regulations do not allow for extensions beyond 52 weeks.
McCall subsequently appealed the Referee's decision to the UCBR, which issued a Merits Order on August 26, 2025, affirming the Referee's findings. The Board noted that even if McCall's claims were locked, there was still no credible evidence that she sought backdating prior to December 2024, which was nearly two years after the weeks she was claiming. The Board stated, “There is no credible evidence that [McCall] sought backdating earlier than December of 2024.”
Following the Board's decision, McCall filed for reconsideration, expressing confusion about the process and reiterating her claims. However, the Board denied her request for reconsideration on September 3, 2025, leading McCall to appeal again, this time to the Commonwealth Court.
In her appeal, McCall raised several issues related to the Merits Order but did not directly address the Reconsideration Order, which was the only order being reviewed by the court. The court noted that issues not raised in the petition for review are considered waived. As a result, the court could only review the denial of reconsideration.
Judge Stacy Wallace, writing for the court, stated, “We agree with the Board. Pa.R.A.P. 2116(a) pertinently provides that no question will be considered unless it is stated in the statement of questions involved.” The court emphasized that McCall's brief did not address the sole issue of whether the Board erred in denying her request for reconsideration. Consequently, the court affirmed the Board's decision.
The ruling has implications for McCall and others in similar situations, as it reinforces the importance of adhering to procedural requirements when appealing decisions related to unemployment benefits. The court highlighted that a request for reconsideration will only be granted for good cause and in the absence of prejudice to any party, and that a denial may be reversed only for clear abuse of discretion.
Moving forward, this ruling serves as a reminder for claimants to ensure they follow the proper procedures when applying for unemployment benefits and to provide adequate evidence to support their claims. The court's decision also underscores the challenges faced by individuals representing themselves in legal proceedings, as they must navigate complex rules and regulations without the assistance of legal counsel.
As for what’s next, McCall may have limited options for further appeal. The court's ruling is final unless a higher court decides to take up the case, which is not indicated in the current filings. Details were not available in the court filing regarding any related cases or potential further appeals.
Read Next
Court affirms denial of zoning variance for Wind Gap project
Court affirms arbitration ruling in PSU union dispute
Court Quashes Appeal by Clay Caldwell Over Timeliness Issues
New Jersey Tax Court dismisses property tax appeal case
Arizona Court affirms attorney fee award in divorce case
Arizona court rules on Nicholas Didur's civil rights appeal










