A Pennsylvania court has affirmed a decision by the Office of Open Records (OOR) that denied a request for documents related to a traffic stop made by Aiden Geist. This ruling impacts individuals seeking transparency in law enforcement procedures under the Right-to-Know Law (RTKL). The case highlights the challenges of obtaining public records from state agencies.
The Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania ruled on November 16, 2026, in the case A. Geist v. Pennsylvania State Police (PSP), docket number 43 C.D. 2026. The court's decision is significant for those who rely on public records to hold government entities accountable.
Background
Aiden Geist, the petitioner in this case, was involved in a traffic stop on October 26, 2025, in Fort Washington, Pennsylvania. Following the incident, he filed a complaint with the PSP's Internal Affairs Division. On November 5, 2025, Geist submitted a request under the RTKL to obtain the name, rank, and identification number of the trooper who conducted the traffic stop.
The PSP responded to Geist's request by denying it, stating that they did not possess any records that matched his request. Geist appealed this decision to the OOR on December 12, 2025, arguing that the PSP had not conducted a thorough search for the requested information. The OOR invited both parties to provide additional information regarding the request.
The Ruling
On January 9, 2026, the OOR upheld the PSP's denial, concluding that the agency had satisfied its burden of proof in demonstrating that it did not possess the records sought by Geist. The OOR found that the PSP had conducted a comprehensive search of its databases and systems. The court's opinion stated, "The PSP reviewed the Request and searched all PSP databases and the Axon system where audio/video records are stored for evidence of any PSP records that may identify the occurrence."
After the OOR's decision, Geist appealed to the Commonwealth Court, which reviewed the case. The court found that the PSP's affidavit, provided by its open records officer, was sufficient evidence to support the agency's claim that no responsive records existed. The court noted that the PSP had conducted a thorough search and had contacted relevant departments to verify the absence of records.
Impact
This ruling reinforces the standards for how public agencies must respond to records requests under the RTKL. It clarifies that while agencies must make a good faith effort to locate records, they are not required to create records that do not exist. The court emphasized that the burden of proof lies with the agency to show that requested records do not exist, but it also acknowledged that agencies cannot be compelled to produce records they do not have.
The decision may affect future requests for public records, particularly those involving law enforcement agencies. It highlights the importance of clear communication and thorough searches by agencies when responding to requests for information. Individuals seeking records may need to provide detailed information to assist agencies in locating the requested documents.
What's Next
Geist's options for appeal appear limited following this ruling, as the Commonwealth Court has affirmed the OOR's decision. There is no indication in the court filing that there are related cases pending that could influence this matter further. Details were not available in the court filing.
Read Next
Court affirms denial of zoning variance for Wind Gap project
Court affirms arbitration ruling in PSU union dispute
Court Quashes Appeal by Clay Caldwell Over Timeliness Issues
New Jersey Tax Court dismisses property tax appeal case
Arizona Court affirms attorney fee award in divorce case
Arizona court rules on Nicholas Didur's civil rights appeal










