The California Court of Appeal has upheld the termination of Harold Macias, a correctional officer, after he was involved in an off-duty altercation and subsequently lied during an investigation. The decision, filed on November 16, 2026, affects Macias, the California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation, and the State Personnel Board. This ruling underscores the accountability expected from public employees, particularly those in law enforcement roles.
The case stems from an incident that occurred in May 2021, when Macias and his girlfriend visited several bars in Sacramento. After a verbal altercation with Joseph Burkley, a member of the public, the situation escalated into a physical confrontation. Macias later attempted to punch Burkley through the window of a vehicle, resulting in Burkley shooting Macias in the neck. Following the incident, Macias was terminated from his position for his conduct and for lying during an internal investigation.
The dispute began when the Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation terminated Macias's employment, citing his involvement in the altercation and dishonesty during the investigation. Macias appealed the termination to the State Personnel Board, where an administrative law judge (ALJ) found him to be an unreliable narrator. Although the ALJ dismissed some charges, he concluded that Macias's actions constituted inexcusable neglect of duty and other failures of good behavior, justifying his dismissal. The Board adopted the ALJ's decision, leading Macias to seek judicial review in the trial court.
In the trial court, Macias argued that the Department failed to establish a connection between his off-duty conduct and his role as a correctional officer. He also claimed that the Board violated his due process rights by sustaining his termination based on different factual grounds than those outlined in the notice of adverse action. However, the trial court denied his petition, affirming the Board's decision.
The Court of Appeal ruled that the Board's findings were supported by substantial evidence. The ruling highlighted that Macias's off-duty conduct discredited himself and the Department, leading to a loss of confidence in his judgment. The court stated, "Macias has displayed a lack of self-control, a failure of good judgment, and a tendency to use unreasonable and unnecessary force to resolve disputes." This assessment was crucial in determining the appropriateness of the termination.
The court also addressed Macias's argument regarding due process, noting that he received adequate notice of the charges against him. The notice detailed the events leading to his termination and provided a clear basis for the disciplinary action. The court explained that the nature of Macias's conduct was sufficient to justify the Department's actions, regardless of who instigated the altercation.
This ruling has significant implications for public employees, particularly those in law enforcement. It reinforces the expectation that correctional officers must maintain a high standard of conduct both on and off duty. The court's decision serves as a reminder that public trust is paramount in law enforcement roles, and any conduct that undermines that trust can result in severe consequences.
Moving forward, Macias has the option to appeal the decision to the California Supreme Court, although it is unclear if he will pursue that route. The outcome of this case may influence future disciplinary actions against public employees, particularly in cases involving off-duty conduct and the standards of behavior expected from law enforcement personnel.
Read Next
California Court upholds murder conviction of Rashad Ware
California Court upholds conviction of Jesus Valencia for abuse
California Court of Appeal affirms judgment in Ybarra case
Court affirms summary judgment in legal malpractice case
Court upholds dismissal of defamation case against attorney
Court denies wife's petition to reopen divorce decree










