The Illinois Appellate Court has ruled against a mother seeking to relocate with her child to Canada, affirming a lower court's decision that awarded the majority of parenting time to the father. The court's ruling, issued on November 16, 2026, in the case of In re Parentage of E.H. (Docket No. 5-26-0484), underscores the importance of maintaining stability for children in custody disputes.
The case involves Shawn P. Harvey, the father, and Audrey C. Durrant, the mother, who have been embroiled in a custody battle over their son, E.H., since their relationship ended in early 2021. The decision is critical as it sets a precedent for how courts may evaluate relocation requests in custody cases, particularly when the proposed move could affect the child's stability.
Background
Shawn P. Harvey and Audrey C. Durrant are the parents of E.H., born in October 2015. The couple had a long-term relationship but never married. Following their separation, Harvey filed a petition in Florida to establish paternity and seek parenting time. In 2022, Durrant sought to relocate to Illinois for a job opportunity, which the Florida court initially approved, establishing a long-distance parenting plan.
After moving to Illinois, Durrant filed a petition to enroll the Florida judgment and requested full custodial rights. The court granted her request, but conflicts arose regarding parenting time and communication between the parents. In 2023, the court found Durrant in violation of the Florida parenting order and established a temporary parenting schedule.
As the case progressed, Durrant filed multiple petitions regarding parenting time and alleged that Harvey's behavior posed risks to E.H. In early 2025, Durrant expressed her intent to relocate to New York City for a job but later withdrew that petition. In June 2025, Durrant moved to Canada with E.H. without proper notification to Harvey, leading to further legal complications.
The Ruling
The Appellate Court ruled that Durrant did not meet her burden of proving that relocating to Canada was in E.H.'s best interest. The court emphasized that stability is crucial for children, particularly in custody cases. The ruling stated, "We affirm the order of the circuit court denying the mother’s petition to relocate and allocating the majority of parenting time to the father where mother did not sustain her burden of proving that the proposed relocation was in the best interest of the child."
The court's decision was delivered by Justice Hackett, with Justice Clarke concurring and Justice Sholar dissenting. The ruling highlighted the need for a thorough examination of the child's best interests, including factors such as the mental and physical health of both parents and the child's need for stability.
Impact
This ruling has significant implications for custody cases in Illinois and potentially beyond. It reinforces the principle that courts prioritize the stability and best interests of the child when considering relocation requests. Parents seeking to move with their children must provide compelling evidence that the move will benefit the child, particularly in cases where the other parent is actively involved in the child's life.
The decision may also influence how courts assess the behavior and circumstances of both parents in custody disputes. By emphasizing the need for stability, the ruling suggests that courts may be less inclined to approve relocation requests that could disrupt a child's established routine and relationships.
What's Next
Details regarding whether Durrant plans to appeal the ruling were not available in the court filing. However, given the contentious nature of the case, further legal actions may arise as both parents continue to navigate their custody arrangement.
Read Next
Illinois court upholds pretrial detention of Derrick Collins
Illinois court upholds conviction of man resisting officers
Illinois court revives homeowner's lawsuit against garage builder
California Court of Appeal rules on hospital lien dispute
California Court Grants Pretrial Release in Murder Case
Hawaii Court Denies Appeal in Immigration Consequences Case










