The Illinois Appellate Court recently ruled in favor of homeowner Herbert Lowe, reviving his lawsuit against Garage 2017 LLC, doing business as Danley’s Garage World (DGW). The court found that a lower court had improperly dismissed Lowe's complaint regarding alleged construction defects in a garage built by DGW. This ruling is significant for homeowners seeking to hold contractors accountable for defective work.
The case, known as Lowe v. Garage, was filed under docket number 1-25-2539 and was decided on November 16, 2026. The appellate court's decision allows Lowe to pursue claims against DGW for alleged violations of consumer fraud and warranties related to the construction of his garage.
Background
Herbert Lowe contracted with DGW in September 2022 to demolish an old garage and construct a new one on his property in Chicago. The total contract price was $22,050, to be paid in three installments. After paying two-thirds of the fee, Lowe terminated DGW's services, leading to a lawsuit from DGW in 2023 to recover the remaining balance of $7,350. The court awarded DGW $5,850 in that case.
In 2025, after a city building inspector raised concerns about the garage's construction, Lowe filed a new lawsuit against DGW, citing seven deficiencies in the work. DGW responded by seeking to dismiss Lowe's complaint, arguing that res judicata applied because Lowe could have raised these issues in the 2023 lawsuit. The circuit court agreed and dismissed Lowe's complaint, prompting Lowe to appeal the decision.
The Ruling
The Illinois Appellate Court reversed the lower court's dismissal, stating that DGW did not meet its burden to show that Lowe could have known about the alleged defects at the time of the previous lawsuit. The court emphasized that the dismissal at the pleading stage was premature, noting, "Whatever may come of this res judicata defense down the road, after discovery, dismissal at the pleading stage was premature."
The court further explained that the doctrine of res judicata prevents multiple lawsuits between the same parties for the same facts and issues. However, it also noted that if a claim exists and a litigant does not discover it despite exercising due diligence, res judicata does not apply. The court stated, "If Lowe was unaware of these defects and could not have discovered them through the exercise of reasonable diligence, then res judicata will not bar his claim for them."
Impact
This ruling has significant implications for homeowners and contractors in Illinois. It clarifies that homeowners may pursue claims for construction defects even after a related lawsuit has concluded, as long as they can demonstrate that they were not aware of the defects at the time of the earlier case. This decision reinforces the importance of due diligence in uncovering construction issues and allows homeowners to seek redress for potentially serious defects that may not be immediately apparent.
The ruling also sets a precedent for future cases involving construction defects and the application of res judicata. Homeowners who discover issues after the completion of construction may now have a clearer path to hold contractors accountable for their work.
What's Next
The case is now remanded to the lower court for further proceedings. DGW may still pursue its res judicata defense after discovery, but for now, Lowe's claims will proceed in court.
Read Next
Illinois court rules on property division in divorce case
Illinois court upholds dismissal of Blackman's appeal
Illinois court upholds denial of pretrial release for Cagle
Court upholds dismissal of defamation case against attorney
Court denies wife's petition to reopen divorce decree
Court affirms termination of father's parental rights in PA










