The Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals has upheld a lower court's ruling affirming Maryland's authority to regulate sports wagering, impacting KalshiEX LLC's operations. The court ruled that the Commodity Exchange Act does not preempt Maryland's gaming laws, allowing the state to enforce its regulations against KalshiEX's sports event contracts.

This decision affects KalshiEX, a federally regulated trading platform that allows users to trade contracts based on the outcomes of sporting events. The ruling signifies the ongoing tension between state and federal regulations in the rapidly evolving landscape of sports betting.

Background

KalshiEX LLC, the appellant in this case, operates a designated contract market (DCM) overseen by the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC). The platform allows users to trade standardized financial contracts tied to future events, including sports outcomes. Unlike traditional sportsbooks, KalshiEX does not take the opposite side of bets; instead, users trade directly with one another.

Maryland law requires that sports wagering be conducted only by licensed operators. The Maryland Lottery and Gaming Control Commission (MLGCC) and the Maryland Lottery and Gaming Control Agency oversee these regulations. In April 2025, the MLGCC issued a cease-and-desist letter to KalshiEX, asserting that the company was unlawfully offering sports wagering without the required state license.

In response, KalshiEX filed a lawsuit against several Maryland officials, including the Attorney General, claiming that the Commodity Exchange Act preempted state laws governing sports wagering. The company sought both declaratory and injunctive relief, arguing that it should be exempt from Maryland's licensing requirements.

The Ruling

The Fourth Circuit Court affirmed the district court's decision, which had denied KalshiEX's motion for a preliminary injunction. The district court concluded that even if KalshiEX's sports event contracts were considered swaps under the Commodity Exchange Act, the Act did not clearly preempt Maryland's authority to regulate gambling.

The court stated, "Congress did not treat every derivative contract traded on a DCM alike. It granted the CFTC exclusive jurisdiction over transactions 'traded or executed' on DCMs while separately recognizing that certain event contracts involving gaming may not be listed or traded on a DCM."

Judges Gregory, Thacker, and Benjamin presided over the case, with Judge Gregory and Judge Thacker concurring in the opinion. Judge Benjamin dissented, highlighting the ongoing debate over the classification of KalshiEX's contracts as swaps.

Impact

This ruling has significant implications for KalshiEX and other similar platforms operating in states with strict gaming regulations. The court's decision reinforces the authority of state governments to regulate sports wagering, even in the context of federally regulated exchanges. It also highlights the complexities of federal preemption in areas traditionally governed by state law.

As more states explore the legalization of sports betting, this case may set a precedent for how state and federal laws interact in the realm of gaming. The ruling indicates that companies like KalshiEX must navigate both federal and state regulations, potentially complicating their operations.

What's Next

KalshiEX may seek further legal recourse, including a possible appeal to the U.S. Supreme Court. The ongoing legal battles surrounding sports wagering and the classification of event contracts suggest that this issue will continue to evolve in the coming years.