The Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals recently ruled against Antonio Cabrera Angel and Maria de Lourdes Blas Pablo, denying their petition for cancellation of removal. The couple, both Mexican citizens, faced deportation after entering the United States illegally. The court's decision affects their future in the U.S. and highlights the challenges many immigrant families face in similar situations.
Angel and Blas Pablo had lived in Smyrna, Tennessee, for many years, raising their three children, all U.S. citizens. Their case underscores the complexities of immigration law, particularly regarding the hardships that families may face if they are forced to return to their home country.
Background
Antonio Cabrera Angel entered the United States illegally in 1998 but was deported shortly after. He returned two days later and settled in Smyrna, where he has lived since. Maria de Lourdes Blas Pablo entered the U.S. illegally in 2004, and the couple married in 2009. They have three children: a 21-year-old daughter and two younger sons, aged 16 and 14.
In 2017, the Department of Homeland Security initiated removal proceedings against Angel and Blas Pablo. They conceded to having entered the country illegally and applied for cancellation of removal, arguing that their deportation would cause exceptional hardship to their children. They claimed that life in Mexico would expose their children to worse healthcare, education, and increased crime.
The Ruling
The Sixth Circuit Court, led by Judge Jeffrey S. Sutton, ruled against the couple, stating that substantial evidence supported the Board of Immigration Appeals' (BIA) decision to deny their applications. The court concluded that Angel and Blas Pablo failed to demonstrate that their removal would cause their children exceptional and extremely unusual hardship.
The court ruled, "the loss of financial prospects... and reduced educational opportunities alone do not satisfy this imposing standard."
The judges emphasized that the hardships faced by the couple were not significantly different from those typically experienced by families facing deportation. They noted that while the couple expressed concerns about employment, healthcare, and education in Mexico, these issues did not rise to the level of exceptional hardship required by immigration law.
Impact
This ruling has significant implications for immigrant families seeking relief from deportation. The court's decision reinforces the strict standards set forth in the Immigration and Nationality Act, which requires proof of exceptional hardship for cancellation of removal. The ruling may deter other families in similar situations from pursuing similar appeals, knowing the high bar they must meet.
Moreover, the decision highlights the challenges faced by individuals with disabilities, such as Angel, who may struggle to find employment in their home countries. The court acknowledged the couple's concerns but ultimately found that their fears did not meet the legal standard for hardship.
What's Next
Angel and Blas Pablo can potentially seek further legal recourse, but the likelihood of success in an appeal remains uncertain. The court's ruling sets a precedent that may affect future immigration cases, particularly those involving claims of hardship. Details were not available in the court filing regarding any related cases pending.
Read Next
Court affirms ruling on abandoned street in South Euclid
Court denies asylum petition from Colombian mother, child
Court affirms ruling in sexual harassment case against OSU
Ninth Circuit denies petition from Salvadoran man facing removal
Ninth Circuit rules on immigration case of Joel Soto Muñoz
Ninth Circuit denies asylum petition for Colombian man










