The Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals has denied an asylum petition filed by Geraldine Faizuly Doza Castro and her minor child, both Colombian citizens. The court ruled against their claims for asylum, withholding of removal, and protection under the Convention Against Torture. The decision comes after the immigration judge and the Board of Immigration Appeals had previously rejected their requests for relief. This ruling affects Doza Castro and her child, who sought safety in the United States due to threats they faced in Colombia.
The case, identified as 26-3157, stems from a series of events that began in December 2021 when Doza Castro and her family witnessed a violent robbery in their hometown of San Pablo, Colombia. Following the incident, Doza Castro’s mother identified one of the robbers to the police, which led to threats and intimidation from the suspect and his gang. The family faced harassment, including rocks thrown at their home and threats against their lives. In response, Doza Castro’s mother sought a protection order from the Colombian ombudsman’s office, but the request was placed on a waitlist.
In 2022, after entering the United States without permission, Doza Castro applied for asylum, claiming she faced persecution as a witness to a crime. She also sought withholding of removal and protection under the Convention Against Torture, arguing that the threats against her family constituted a risk of torture. However, the immigration judge denied her application, stating that being a witness to a crime does not qualify as a recognized social group for asylum purposes. The judge also noted that Doza Castro failed to demonstrate that the Colombian government would acquiesce to any potential torture.
The Board of Immigration Appeals upheld the immigration judge's decision, stating that Doza Castro's appeal did not adequately challenge the judge's findings regarding the lack of a cognizable social group. The Board emphasized that her brief did not sufficiently address the critical issues of particularity and social distinctiveness of her proposed group. As a result, the Board deemed her claims forfeited.
In its ruling, the Sixth Circuit Court, which included Judges R. Guy Cole, Jr., Jeffrey S. Sutton, and Amul R. Thapar, affirmed the Board's decision. Judge Sutton noted, "The immigration judge rejected this proposed group because it lacked particularity and social distinctiveness." The court also pointed out that the immigration judge's conclusions were supported by substantial evidence, including the fact that Doza Castro and her family did not report the threats to the police.
The court further explained that to qualify for asylum, an applicant must demonstrate membership in a particular social group that is recognized under immigration law. The court ruled, "The problem for Doza Castro is that she never established membership within a cognizable social group." This ruling reinforces the importance of adequately presenting and developing arguments in immigration cases.
In assessing the Convention Against Torture claim, the court found that Doza Castro did not provide sufficient evidence to show that Colombian officials would acquiesce to any potential torture. The court highlighted that the police had responded to the initial robbery incident and that the family’s failure to report the threats undermined their claim. The court stated, "Neither Doza Castro nor her relatives, notably, reported the threats they received to the police. That omission makes it difficult to show that the police knew about any torture, let alone willfully turned a blind eye to it or participated in it."
Doza Castro's arguments regarding the Colombian ombudsman’s office and the general conditions in Colombia were also dismissed by the court. The court ruled that the ombudsman’s actions did not amount to acquiescence to torture, as the office merely placed the family’s request for protection on a waitlist and emphasized the need for a thorough investigation.
This ruling has significant implications for Doza Castro and her child, who now face the possibility of removal from the United States. The decision also underscores the challenges faced by asylum seekers in proving their claims, particularly in demonstrating membership in a recognized social group and showing government acquiescence to threats or violence.
Looking ahead, it remains unclear whether Doza Castro and her child will pursue further legal action. The court's ruling can potentially be appealed, but details regarding any plans for appeal or related cases were not available in the court filing. For now, the denial of their asylum petition stands, leaving the family in a precarious situation as they navigate their future in the U.S.
















