A New York appellate court has reversed a lower court's decision in a medical malpractice case involving Dr. Frederick Sabido. The ruling allows the plaintiff, Peter Mackauer, to continue his lawsuit, which alleges that Sabido performed unnecessary surgery, resulting in significant complications and suffering for Mackauer.
This decision is crucial for Mackauer, who claims that Sabido's actions led to a prolonged hospitalization and ongoing pain. The case highlights the importance of informed consent in medical procedures and the responsibilities of healthcare providers.
The dispute began when Mackauer filed a lawsuit against Sabido, asserting claims of medical malpractice and lack of informed consent. Mackauer alleged that Sabido unnecessarily removed part of his colon, which caused him to endure complications and a lengthy recovery process.
The case was filed in Richmond County and eventually reached the Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York. The lower court had granted Sabido's motion for summary judgment, effectively dismissing Mackauer's claims. However, Mackauer appealed this decision, arguing that there were significant issues of fact that warranted a trial.
In its ruling on November 18, 2026, the court found that the lower court had erred in granting summary judgment. The court stated, "The defendant failed to establish his prima facie entitlement to judgment as a matter of law dismissing the cause of action alleging lack of informed consent." This indicates that the court believed there was enough evidence for the case to proceed.
The judges involved in the ruling were Lara J. Genovesi, Valerie Brathwaite Nelson, Lillian Wan, and Laurence L. Love. They concluded that Mackauer's expert testimony raised significant questions about whether Sabido had adhered to the accepted standards of medical care.
The court noted that to prove a medical malpractice claim, a plaintiff must show that the healthcare provider deviated from accepted medical practices and that this deviation caused harm. In this case, Mackauer's expert claimed that Sabido's actions were not only unnecessary but also harmful, which established a triable issue of fact.
Additionally, the court addressed the issue of informed consent, stating that a patient must be fully informed of the risks and alternatives associated with a medical procedure. The court found that the consent form signed by Mackauer did not adequately document the specific risks or alternatives related to the colon surgery.
The judges pointed out that the testimony from both parties contradicted whether Sabido had properly informed Mackauer about the risks and alternatives. The court emphasized that the mere existence of a signed consent form does not automatically absolve a physician from liability.
The ruling is significant as it reinforces the standards for informed consent in medical procedures, ensuring that patients are adequately informed before undergoing treatment. It also highlights the importance of expert testimony in medical malpractice cases, as conflicting opinions can lead to trials rather than dismissals.
This decision may have broader implications for medical malpractice law in New York. It underscores the necessity for healthcare providers to maintain clear communication with their patients and to provide comprehensive information about treatment options.
Going forward, the case will proceed to trial unless a further appeal is filed. Mackauer's legal team will likely prepare to present their evidence in court, while Sabido's defense will continue to argue that his actions were appropriate.
As of now, there are no indications that this case will be appealed to a higher court, but the parties may seek further legal options depending on the trial's outcome. The ruling sets a precedent for similar cases involving medical malpractice and informed consent, potentially influencing future litigation in this area.
Read Next
New York court affirms robbery conviction of Edgar Quinones
New York court modifies sentence in assault case against Pryce
New York court upholds sentence in People v. Price case
Court denies plaintiff's request to join two injury cases
Court upholds ruling in personal injury case against landlord
NY Appellate Court Rules in Favor of UPS in Injury Case









