In a recent ruling, the Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York decided in favor of United Parcel Service, Inc. (UPS) regarding a personal injury case. The court overturned a previous decision that had denied UPS's motion to dismiss claims made by Ashante D. Callender and others, who alleged injuries from a car accident involving a UPS delivery truck. This ruling is significant as it highlights the weight of documentary evidence in personal injury claims.
The case, titled Callender v. United Parcel Service, Inc., was filed under docket number 2025-00331. The court's decision was issued on November 18, 2026, and it reversed an earlier order from the Supreme Court, Kings County, which had denied UPS's attempt to dismiss the case based on evidence presented.
The plaintiffs, Ashante D. Callender and others, claimed that a UPS delivery truck, driven by Ricardo Castillo, collided with their vehicle, a white Toyota Camry, on November 28, 2023. The accident occurred around 7:00 p.m. on Gates Avenue. The plaintiffs filed their lawsuit in June 2024, seeking damages for personal injuries they alleged resulted from the incident.
UPS responded to the lawsuit by filing a pre-answer motion to dismiss the first and second causes of action against it. The company argued that documentary evidence, specifically a dashboard-camera videotape, showed that the UPS vehicle was stopped in bumper-to-bumper traffic at the time of the accident. The plaintiffs contended that the videotape did not capture the actual moment of impact, implying that it could not be used to dismiss their claims.
The Supreme Court initially sided with the plaintiffs, stating that the videotape did not provide conclusive evidence of the events leading to the accident. However, the Appellate Division disagreed, stating that the videotape was authenticated by Castillo, who confirmed it accurately depicted the events. The court noted that the video clearly showed the UPS truck was stationary and did not strike the plaintiffs' vehicle.
In its ruling, the court stated, "the videotape established that the United vehicle was stopped at the time of impact and did not strike the vehicle occupied by the plaintiffs." The court emphasized that the plaintiffs' argument about a possible obstruction from the UPS vehicle was based on speculation, which did not hold up against the documentary evidence presented.
The Appellate Division concluded that the videotape constituted documentary evidence that conclusively established the plaintiffs had no cause of action against UPS. As a result, the court reversed the lower court's order and granted UPS's motion to dismiss the first and second causes of action.
This ruling has significant implications for personal injury cases, particularly those involving vehicle accidents. It underscores the importance of documentary evidence, such as video footage, in establishing the facts of a case. The decision may influence how similar cases are approached in the future, particularly regarding the use of technology in documenting incidents.
The outcome of this case affects not only the plaintiffs but also sets a precedent for how courts may handle personal injury claims involving commercial vehicles. The ruling demonstrates that if documentary evidence can clearly refute a plaintiff's claims, courts may be inclined to dismiss those claims early in the proceedings.
Looking ahead, it remains to be seen whether the plaintiffs will seek to appeal this decision. The court's ruling provides a strong precedent for UPS and potentially other companies facing similar claims. There are no known related cases pending that would directly impact this ruling.
Read Next
New York court affirms robbery conviction of Edgar Quinones
New York court modifies sentence in assault case against Pryce
New York court upholds sentence in People v. Price case
Court reverses summary judgment in medical malpractice case
Court denies plaintiff's request to join two injury cases
Court upholds ruling in personal injury case against landlord









