A New York appellate court recently ruled on a personal injury case involving a worker injured while replacing a motor on a garage door. The decision affects how liability is determined under state labor laws, particularly regarding workplace safety. The case, Nunez v. Town of Ramapo, was decided on November 18, 2026, and has implications for workers and employers alike.
The plaintiff, Erwin Mercedes Nunez, was injured when the garage door he was working on suddenly opened, causing him and the scissor lift he was on to fall. This incident occurred while Nunez was performing work for a company contracted by the Town of Ramapo. The case centers on whether the town, as the property owner, failed to provide a safe working environment, which is a requirement under New York's Labor Law.
Nunez filed a lawsuit against the Town of Ramapo seeking damages for his injuries. The case was first heard in the Supreme Court of Rockland County, where both parties filed motions for summary judgment. The court's July 10, 2025 order denied the defendant's motion to dismiss the case and also denied Nunez's motion for summary judgment on liability.
The Town of Ramapo argued that it should not be held liable for Nunez's injuries, while Nunez contended that the town violated Labor Law § 240(1), which mandates that property owners ensure appropriate safety devices are provided to workers at risk of falling. This law holds owners and contractors strictly liable for injuries caused by their failure to do so.
The appellate court, consisting of Judges Mark C. Dillon, Helen Voutsinas, Laurence L. Love, and Elena Goldberg Velazquez, upheld the lower court's decision. They ruled that the actions taken by Nunez in replacing the garage door motor qualified as a repair under Labor Law § 240(1). The court stated, "the act of removing the old motor and installing a new motor on the garage door constituted a repair within the purview of Labor Law § 240(1)."
Additionally, the court found that there were unresolved factual issues regarding whether Nunez's own actions contributed to his injuries. The court noted that both parties had conflicting evidence about whether Nunez could have safely secured his safety harness before the accident. This led the judges to conclude that neither party had sufficiently proven their case for summary judgment.
Furthermore, the court addressed the defendant's claims regarding common-law negligence and violations of Labor Law § 200, which requires employers to provide a safe working environment. The court ruled that the Town of Ramapo did not meet the burden of proof needed to dismiss these claims, as there were still questions about whether the town had created a dangerous condition that led to Nunez's injuries.
The court emphasized that the duty to provide a safe workplace does not extend to hazards that are inherent to the work being performed. However, the evidence presented by the Town of Ramapo did not eliminate the possibility that they had created or were aware of the dangerous conditions that led to Nunez's fall.
This ruling is significant for both workers and employers in New York. It reinforces the strict liability standard set by Labor Law § 240(1) for injuries related to elevation risks. This means that property owners and contractors must be vigilant in ensuring safety devices and protocols are in place, or they may be held liable for injuries that occur on their premises.
The decision also highlights the importance of thorough documentation and safety measures in the workplace. Employers must ensure that all safety devices are available and that workers are trained to use them properly. Failure to do so could result in legal consequences, as seen in this case.
Looking ahead, this ruling may influence similar cases involving workplace injuries in New York. It underscores the need for employers to take proactive steps in ensuring worker safety, especially in situations involving elevation-related tasks. The decision could also serve as a precedent for future cases where the interpretation of Labor Law § 240(1) and common-law negligence is at issue.
The Town of Ramapo has the option to appeal this decision to a higher court. However, details on whether they will pursue this route were not available in the court filing. The outcome of this case may also affect other pending cases involving workplace safety and liability under New York law.
Read Next
New York court affirms robbery conviction of Edgar Quinones
New York court modifies sentence in assault case against Pryce
New York court upholds sentence in People v. Price case
Court denies plaintiff's request to join two injury cases
Court upholds ruling in personal injury case against landlord
NY Appellate Court Rules in Favor of UPS in Injury Case









