The Oregon Court of Appeals has affirmed the Department of State Lands' (DSL) jurisdiction over certain features of a sand and gravel mine owned by Knife River Corporation - NW. This ruling, issued on November 18, 2026, clarifies the application of Oregon's Removal-Fill Law, which regulates activities affecting the state's waterways. The decision impacts how mining operations near water bodies are regulated, particularly concerning environmental protections.
Knife River Corporation, which operates a mining site bordering the Willamette River, challenged DSL's determination that specific areas of its property were subject to state regulation. The court's ruling is significant as it reinforces the state's authority to regulate activities that may affect the environment, particularly in areas that can connect to natural waterways.
The dispute arose when Knife River Corporation sought a jurisdictional determination from DSL regarding its mining features, specifically Wetland F and several mining pits. These features were created for mining purposes and did not initially connect to the Willamette River. However, the river's water levels can rise enough to create a surface connection with these features several times a year.
Initially, DSL determined that these features qualified as "waters of the state" under the Removal-Fill Law, which requires a permit for any removal or fill activities in state waters. Knife River Corporation contested this decision, arguing that the features should be exempt from regulation as they were created entirely from upland for surface mining.
After a contested hearing, an administrative law judge (ALJ) initially sided with Knife River, stating that the features did not qualify as waters of the state. However, DSL later reversed this decision, asserting that the features were indeed part of the Willamette River and thus subject to regulation. Knife River Corporation then appealed this final order to the Oregon Court of Appeals.
In its ruling, the court upheld DSL's interpretation of the Removal-Fill Law and its regulations. The opinion, authored by Presiding Judge Kamins, stated, "Because that interpretation is plausible, is not an impermissible expansion, and was not applied erroneously, we affirm." The court emphasized that the jurisdictional boundaries of a river include areas that have intermittent surface connections with the main water body, even if those areas were artificially created.
The court's decision clarified two key points regarding DSL's jurisdiction. First, it affirmed that rivers are jurisdictional up to the ordinary high water line, which can be determined by observing annual high water events. Second, it noted that the presence of an intermittent connection to the river means that the features in question fall under DSL's jurisdiction, regardless of their status as artificially created wetlands or ponds.
This ruling has broader implications for environmental regulation in Oregon. It reinforces the state's authority to regulate activities that could impact waterways, particularly in cases where artificial features may connect to natural bodies of water. The court's decision emphasizes the importance of maintaining environmental protections and ensuring that mining operations comply with state laws.
Looking ahead, this ruling could set a precedent for future cases involving similar disputes over jurisdictional determinations under the Removal-Fill Law. It highlights the need for mining companies and other entities operating near waterways to be aware of their regulatory obligations, particularly in light of changing environmental conditions.
Knife River Corporation has the option to appeal the ruling to the Oregon Supreme Court, but details regarding any potential appeal or related cases were not available in the court filing. The outcome of this case may influence how other mining operations approach their compliance with environmental regulations in Oregon.














