The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit affirmed the sentence of Hector Cruz Ciprian, who violated the terms of his supervised release and illegally reentered the United States. This ruling, filed on November 18, 2026, affects Ciprian, a Dominican Republic citizen, who was previously sentenced for identity theft and is now facing additional time in prison.
Ciprian's case began when he pleaded guilty in 2021 to charges of false representation of a social security number and aggravated identity theft. The District Court in Massachusetts sentenced him to 30 months in prison and three years of supervised release. A condition of his release was that he could not return to the U.S. without permission from the Department of Homeland Security. After completing his prison term, he was deported to the Dominican Republic in August 2022.
However, Ciprian returned to the U.S. unlawfully in 2023. He was arrested at Newark Liberty International Airport in July 2024 and was indicted for illegal reentry. Following this, his probation officer filed a petition to revoke his supervised release. In February 2025, Ciprian pleaded guilty to the illegal reentry charge, leading to a series of hearings in July 2025 regarding both his supervised release violation and the illegal reentry.
During the hearings, the government recommended a sentence within the guidelines for the supervised release violation, which was between eight to 14 months. Ciprian's defense counsel sought a time-served sentence, which would have been approximately 14 months. The court allowed Ciprian's attorney to consult with him before sentencing, and after a brief discussion, Ciprian waived his right to speak on the supervised release violation.
The court then found that Ciprian had violated his supervised release and sentenced him to 14 months in prison, which would run consecutively to any sentence imposed for the illegal reentry conviction. The court made it clear that it intended for the sentences to be consecutive, despite objections from Ciprian's defense counsel.
After addressing the illegal reentry charge, the court ultimately sentenced Ciprian to 30 months in prison, also to run consecutively to the 14-month sentence for the supervised release violation. Ciprian appealed the decision regarding his revocation sentence, arguing that the court erred by not personally inviting him to speak before imposing the sentence.
The court ruled that there was no plain error in the District Court's actions. It noted that although the court did not personally address Ciprian before sentencing, his attorney had indicated that Ciprian understood the proceedings and waived his right to allocute. The ruling emphasized that Ciprian did not object to this waiver at the time.
Additionally, the court addressed Ciprian's argument that it was premature for the District Court to run his sentences consecutively since the illegal reentry sentence had not yet been imposed. The court rejected this argument, clarifying that the District Court had merely expressed its intent to run the sentences consecutively, and did not make a final decision until after hearing arguments regarding the illegal reentry conviction.
The court concluded that Ciprian's claims did not meet the criteria for plain error review, and thus, the District Court's sentence was affirmed. This ruling is significant as it upholds the authority of the District Court in determining sentences and reinforces the conditions of supervised release.
The implications of this ruling extend beyond Ciprian. It sets a precedent for how courts may handle similar cases involving violations of supervised release and illegal reentry. The decision clarifies the standards for allocution rights and the interpretation of consecutive sentencing under U.S. law.
Moving forward, Ciprian has the option to appeal this ruling, but details regarding any potential appeals or related cases were not available in the court filing. His situation highlights the complexities of immigration law and the consequences of violating terms of supervised release.
Read Next
Court denies Catherine Wakefield's mandamus petition
Third Circuit reverses suppression order in child abuse case
Court denies rehearing in church zoning dispute case
Oregon Court Affirms Conviction of Ricki Scott Collin
Oregon court upholds conviction in sexual abuse case
Oregon Court upholds juvenile delinquency ruling in assault case










