A federal court has denied a request for a default judgment made by Peter Bernegger against the Federal Election Commission (FEC). The ruling, made by Judge Amit P. Mehta in the District Court for the District of Columbia, highlights the importance of following proper procedures when filing complaints with the FEC. This decision affects individuals who may consider filing complaints regarding campaign finance violations.
Bernegger's case stems from a complaint he filed in December 2025 against Senator John Thune and his campaign committee. He claimed the FEC failed to act on his complaint, which he believed was improperly dismissed. The court's ruling emphasizes the necessity for complaints to meet specific legal requirements, which Bernegger's complaint did not.
Background
Peter Bernegger filed a complaint with the FEC in December 2025, targeting Senator John Thune, his campaign committee, Friends of John Thune, and the committee's Treasurer, Nicole Weyers. Bernegger alleged that the FEC had either improperly dismissed his complaint or failed to act on it as required by law. The FEC responded to Bernegger's complaint on December 31, 2025, stating that it could not process the complaint because it was not notarized.
Following this response, Bernegger filed a lawsuit in January 2026, seeking a default judgment against the FEC for its inaction. He argued that the FEC's failure to process his complaint violated his rights under the Federal Election Campaign Act (FECA). However, the court found that Bernegger had not met the necessary legal requirements for his complaint.
The Ruling
In its ruling, the court denied Bernegger's motion for default judgment, stating, "Plaintiff has not, however, shown that the FEC’s inaction was improper." The court explained that the FECA requires complaints to be notarized, and Bernegger's complaint did not comply with this requirement. The FEC had properly notified Bernegger of the defect in his complaint and suggested that he resend a notarized version.
Judge Mehta concluded, "Accordingly, the non-processing of his complaint did not violate FECA, and Plaintiff therefore is not entitled to entry of default judgment." The court also dismissed the case without prejudice, meaning that Bernegger could potentially refile if he corrects the issues with his complaint.
Impact
This ruling serves as a reminder of the importance of adhering to procedural rules when filing complaints with federal agencies like the FEC. Individuals seeking to challenge campaign finance practices must ensure their complaints meet all statutory and regulatory requirements. The decision may discourage future complaints that do not comply with the necessary legal standards, as the court clearly indicated that failure to follow procedures would lead to dismissal.
The ruling may also have broader implications for how individuals interact with the FEC, reinforcing the need for proper documentation and adherence to the law. This case underscores the challenges that individuals may face when navigating the complexities of campaign finance law.
What's Next
Bernegger has the option to appeal the court's decision, but he would need to address the issues identified in the ruling before doing so. There is no indication of a related case pending in the court filing.














