A Vermont court has ruled that QW Durfee Sheet Metal & Roofing, Inc. is owed $27,612 by David Cooper for roofing work completed on a construction project. This decision comes after a dispute over payments for additional work performed by the roofing company. The ruling could impact how subcontractors handle payment disputes in the future.
The case, QW Durfee Sheet Metal & Roofing, Inc. v. David Cooper, was filed in the Vermont Superior Court under docket number 26-cv-1890. The court’s opinion was issued on May 14, 2026, following an evidentiary hearing held on May 11, 2026. The court found that QW Durfee had a reasonable likelihood of recovering the claimed amount, which includes interest and costs.
The parties involved in this case are QW Durfee Sheet Metal & Roofing, Inc., the plaintiff, and David Cooper, the defendant. QW Durfee is a roofing company that entered into a subcontract with Charles Martin, a general contractor, to perform roofing work on a property in Mendon, Vermont. The total contract price for the project was over $1.4 million, with the roofing portion initially set at $55,000. However, during the project, additional work was requested, leading to an increase in the total amount billed by QW Durfee to $58,000.
The dispute arose after the work was completed between June 2024 and July 2025. QW Durfee submitted periodic invoices to Mr. Martin, which were paid until a conflict developed between Mr. Martin and Mr. Cooper. After Mr. Martin left the job, Mr. Cooper assumed the role of general contractor and took on the responsibility of paying subcontractors, including QW Durfee. Despite making partial payments, Mr. Cooper disputed the remaining balance owed to QW Durfee.
During the proceedings, QW Durfee claimed a balance of $27,612.00 owed for the roofing work, which was supported by invoices. Mr. Cooper, however, estimated that the work performed by other workers was worth approximately $9,000, suggesting that the total amount paid was sufficient. The court found no reliable evidence to support Mr. Cooper's claims, noting that he did not provide specific facts to back his estimate.
The court ruled that QW Durfee had established a reasonable likelihood of recovering the amount claimed. The opinion stated, "The evidence shows that the work performed by QW Durfee and for which it billed was contracted for by Mr. Martin and completed without problems." The ruling emphasized that Mr. Cooper had assumed Mr. Martin's obligations as general contractor, which included the duty to pay QW Durfee for the work completed.
As a result of the court's ruling, QW Durfee is entitled to the claimed amount of $27,612, plus interest from 30 days after the final invoice. The court also noted that there was no insurance, bond, or other security available to satisfy the judgment. This ruling reinforces the importance of clear contracts and payment obligations in construction projects.
The impact of this ruling extends beyond the immediate parties involved. It highlights the responsibilities of general contractors when subcontractors are involved and the need for transparency in payment processes. Subcontractors may feel more empowered to pursue claims for unpaid work, knowing that courts may uphold their rights in similar disputes.
Looking ahead, it remains to be seen whether Mr. Cooper will appeal the court's decision. The court filing did not specify any intentions for an appeal, and there is no indication of any related cases pending that could affect this ruling. As the construction industry continues to navigate complex contractual relationships, this case may serve as a reference point for future disputes regarding payment obligations.
Read Next
Vermont court dismisses eviction case against Catherine Morrill
Vermont court rules on timber harvest dispute case
Vermont court rules in favor of Sprague Stonework in contract case
Ninth Circuit upholds labor arbitration ruling in Oregon case
Florida Court Dismisses Appeal in Property Dispute Case
Court rules on Cardinal Midstream v. Energy Transfer case










