The Vermont Superior Court has ruled in favor of Sprague Stonework, LLC in a contract dispute with Seth Jacoby, ordering him to pay $26,094.88 for unpaid work on his property. This decision, issued on November 12, 2026, is significant as it clarifies the obligations of parties in a construction contract, particularly when the terms are not clearly defined.
The case, docket number 22-cv-3302, centers around a fixed-price contract for stone work that Sprague Stonework completed for Jacoby's property in Wilmington, Vermont. The ruling impacts both parties, as it holds Jacoby accountable for the remaining balance owed to Sprague Stonework while also addressing the ambiguities in their agreement.
Background
Sprague Stonework, LLC, led by Steven Sprague, is a business specializing in dry stone wall construction. With nearly five decades of experience, Sprague manages numerous projects annually, primarily in Vermont and New Hampshire. Seth Jacoby, a Massachusetts resident, purchased a property in Wilmington in 2021 and sought to replace a wooden deck with a stone patio and walls.
The dispute arose after Jacoby claimed that certain aspects of the work were either incomplete or deficient. The parties had initially agreed on a contract for $80,000, which was later revised to $40,500 after Jacoby requested to omit the patio stone. The contract was vague, lacking a detailed design or plan, leading to differing interpretations of what work was included.
The case reached the Vermont Superior Court following a bench trial held on October 5 and 15, 2026. During the trial, both parties presented their arguments regarding the scope of the work and the quality of the completed project. Jacoby represented himself, while Sprague was represented by Attorney Lance C. Shader.
The Ruling
The court ruled in favor of Sprague Stonework, concluding that Jacoby failed to prove his claims regarding deficiencies in the work performed. The judge found that the contract did not include an obligation to construct a stone wall on the north side of the house, as Jacoby had alleged. The opinion stated, "The contract did not include the obligation to construct any stone wall on the north side of the house."
Additionally, the court determined that Jacoby had not demonstrated that the hot tub was improperly located or that there were significant deficiencies in the drainage system or the construction of the stone walls. The court emphasized that the lack of a clear design plan contributed to the ambiguity surrounding the contract's terms.
Impact
This ruling has important implications for construction contracts in Vermont. It underscores the necessity for clear and detailed agreements between parties to avoid disputes over contract interpretation. The court's decision reinforces the idea that ambiguity in contracts can lead to unfavorable outcomes for parties who fail to properly document their agreements.
Moving forward, contractors and clients alike may need to ensure that all aspects of a project are clearly defined in writing, including any changes made during the course of the work. This case serves as a reminder that the clarity of communication and documentation is critical in construction projects.
What's Next
Jacoby has the option to appeal the court's decision if he believes there are grounds for doing so. However, details regarding any potential appeal were not available in the court filing. Additionally, there are no related cases pending that have been mentioned in the opinion.
Read Next
Vermont court rules in favor of roofing company in payment dispute
Vermont Court Dismisses Lawsuit Against Fire District Board
Court rules Nature Conservancy can reclaim land from Stratton
Vermont court rules on landlord-tenant dispute over rent
Vermont Court Denies Interlocutory Appeal in Emilius Case
Vermont court strikes risk containment designation for inmate










