A Vermont court has ruled in favor of Nelson Barney, an inmate challenging his classification as a risk to public safety. The court found that the Vermont Department of Corrections failed to follow its own procedures in designating Barney as a Risk Containment (RC) individual. This decision could significantly affect Barney's incarceration conditions and future release opportunities.

Barney, who has been under the supervision of the Department of Corrections for much of his adult life, was convicted in 2023 on charges related to violating a temporary order of abuse prevention. He was sentenced to a maximum date of February 16, 2027. After being released on furlough in February 2024, he was later arrested for new charges in May 2024, which led to a revocation of his furlough.

Following his acquittal on the new charges in January 2025, Barney expected to return to his furlough status. However, he was designated as a risk to public safety under the Risk Sensitive Notification (RSN) classification, which slowed his potential release. The court's ruling on July 1, 2026, addresses Barney's claims regarding the improper procedures followed by the Department of Corrections.

Background

Nelson Barney has been in and out of the Vermont Department of Corrections for over 20 years. He was convicted in 2023 for violating a temporary order of abuse prevention and was sentenced to a maximum date of February 16, 2027. After being released on furlough in February 2024, he was arrested in May of the same year for allegedly attempting to enter his ex-girlfriend's residence, leading to a revocation of his furlough.

Barney was later found not guilty of the new charges in January 2025. Following this acquittal, he anticipated a return to his prior furlough status. However, a Case Staffing committee designated him as a risk to public safety, which imposed restrictions on his potential release. The committee's decision was based on Barney's previous convictions and the incident that led to his arrest.

Barney's legal challenges began after he received a Risk Containment classification in July 2025, which he argued was improper. He claimed the Department of Corrections did not follow its own rules regarding risk assessments and failed to notify him of his rights to provide mitigating information during the classification process.

The Ruling

The Vermont Superior Court ruled that the Department of Corrections had abused its discretion in classifying Barney as a Risk Containment individual. Judge Mary Miles Teachout stated, "The Department failed to establish the basic eligibility of Mr. Barney for risk containment consideration by determining whether or not his conviction was for a Listed Offense, which it was not."

The court found that Barney's current incarceration was based on violations of a temporary order, which does not qualify as a Listed Offense under Vermont law. The ruling emphasized that the Department's failure to follow its own procedures constituted an abuse of discretion.

Additionally, the court noted that Barney was not given the opportunity to provide mitigating information before the committee made its decision. This lack of notification violated the procedural protections outlined in the Department's directives. The court ordered the Risk Containment classification to be expunged and remanded the case back to the Department for further action.

Impact

This ruling has significant implications for Barney's future. By striking down the Risk Containment designation, the court has opened the door for Barney to challenge his current incarceration conditions and potentially seek release under more favorable terms. The court's decision highlights the importance of following established procedures in the classification of inmates and ensures that individuals have the opportunity to present their case adequately.

The ruling may also set a precedent for other inmates challenging similar classifications within the Vermont Department of Corrections. It underscores the necessity for correctional institutions to adhere strictly to their own policies and legal obligations when assessing inmates' risk levels and release eligibility.

What's Next

Following the court's ruling, the Vermont Department of Corrections is required to expunge Barney's Risk Containment classification. It remains unclear if the Department will appeal the decision. Additionally, there may be related cases pending that could further clarify the application of risk assessments in the correctional system.