A Vermont court recently ruled on a significant wrongful death case, denying a motion to amend a complaint that sought to expand the eligibility for damages under the state's Wrongful Death Act. This decision affects the rights of individuals who may not fit the traditional definitions of family but claim a close relationship with a deceased person.
The case, Wendell v. Wagner, was filed in the Vermont Superior Court under docket number 24-cv-5293. The plaintiff, Vickie Wendell, is the executrix of the estate of Stanley M. Borucki, who died in October 2023. Wendell sought to amend the original complaint to include herself and a minor, Skyler Borucki, as recipients of damages. The court's ruling on May 11, 2026, denied this motion, emphasizing the limitations set by existing state law.
Background
The parties involved in this case are Vickie Wendell, representing the estate of Stanley M. Borucki, and Harry Wagner, presumably a defendant in the wrongful death action. The dispute centers around the eligibility for damages under the Vermont Wrongful Death Act, which traditionally limits compensation to specific classes of recipients, such as spouses and children.
Wendell argued that she and Skyler Borucki, who was a foster child and had a close relationship with the deceased, should be allowed to seek damages. She described herself as the functional equivalent of a spouse, stating that she was financially and emotionally dependent on Borucki. Skyler, who was ten years old at the time of Borucki's death, viewed him as a father figure and was in the process of being adopted. However, the adoption petition was filed after Borucki's death, which complicated their claims under the law.
The Ruling
The court ruled against Wendell's motion to amend the complaint, stating that the existing law does not allow for the recovery of damages by individuals outside the specified classes. The ruling highlighted that the Vermont Legislature has not amended the Wrongful Death Act to include broader definitions of family or relationships. The court noted, "The court's responsibility is to apply statutory law as established by the Legislature. Plaintiff seeks to amend the complaint to pursue a recovery not authorized by law." This ruling was made by Superior Judge Mary Miles Teachout, who was specially assigned to the case.
In denying the motion, the court underscored the importance of adhering to statutory limits on wrongful death claims. The judge pointed out that while the Legislature has expanded the definitions in other areas of law, it has not done so in the context of wrongful death damages. This decision reinforces the boundaries set by the state law regarding who can claim damages in such cases.
Impact
The ruling has significant implications for individuals in Vermont who may find themselves in similar situations. It clarifies that only those defined by the law, such as spouses and children, can pursue damages in wrongful death cases. This decision may prompt discussions about the need for legislative changes to address the evolving definitions of family and relationships in society.
Furthermore, the court's decision may discourage future attempts to expand the eligibility for damages in wrongful death claims unless the law is amended. It highlights the challenges faced by individuals who have close relationships with the deceased but do not fit the traditional definitions recognized by the law. The decision could potentially lead to calls for reform in the Wrongful Death Act to accommodate non-traditional family structures.
What's Next
As of now, it is unclear if Wendell plans to appeal the court's decision. The court filing did not provide information on any related cases pending or whether there are plans for legislative changes regarding the Wrongful Death Act. The outcome of this case may influence future discussions on wrongful death claims and the need for legal reforms in Vermont.











