The Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals recently reversed a lower court's decision that allowed Xiaomi to obtain discovery from Advanced Standard Communication, L.L.C. (ASC). This ruling affects ongoing patent infringement proceedings involving Xiaomi and ASC, particularly in the context of a Patent Purchase Agreement (PPA) with ZTE Corporation. The case highlights the complexities of international patent law and the legal standards for discovery in such matters.

The court's ruling came on November 17, 2026, in case number 26-10735. The decision is significant because it addresses the standards under which American courts can compel discovery for use in foreign proceedings.

Background

Xiaomi, a global technology company known for its smartphones and consumer electronics, is involved in patent infringement proceedings against ASC in the European Union’s Unified Patent Court (UPC). Xiaomi sought to obtain ASC’s 2022 Patent Purchase Agreement with ZTE Corporation, which was also a key document in a similar case involving Motorola Mobility and ASC.

The dispute began when Xiaomi filed a request for discovery under 28 U.S.C. § 1782, which allows U.S. courts to assist foreign tribunals by ordering the production of evidence. The district court in Texas initially granted Xiaomi's request, prompting ASC to appeal the decision, arguing that the lower court had made several legal errors in its ruling.

The Ruling

The Fifth Circuit Court reviewed the case and found that the district court had abused its discretion in two key areas. First, the court noted that the district court incorrectly demanded "authoritative proof" that the UPC was unreceptive to American discovery. This standard, according to the Fifth Circuit, was not appropriate and led to a biased assessment of the second Intel factor, which weighs against granting discovery.

The court ruled, “Absent such ‘proof,’ the district court automatically weighed this factor in Xiaomi’s favor.”

Secondly, the Fifth Circuit criticized the district court for not adequately analyzing the third Intel factor, which addresses concerns about circumvention of foreign discovery laws. The Fifth Circuit pointed out that the district court relied on a general principle that there is no foreign discoverability bar under Section 1782, but that principle did not address the specific concerns raised by ASC.

The court stated, “Future developments may suggest the propriety of another application.”

As a result of these findings, the Fifth Circuit reversed the lower court's order, indicating that the Intel factors weighed against allowing discovery at this time.

Impact

This ruling has significant implications for both Xiaomi and ASC, as well as for other companies involved in international patent disputes. The Fifth Circuit's decision reinforces the need for U.S. courts to carefully consider the standards for discovery requests related to foreign proceedings. It suggests that companies cannot simply rely on U.S. courts to obtain evidence that may not be readily available or necessary in foreign jurisdictions.

The ruling also sets a precedent for how courts may handle similar requests in the future. By emphasizing the importance of the Intel factors, the Fifth Circuit has clarified that U.S. courts must be cautious when granting discovery that could potentially interfere with foreign legal processes.

What's Next

While the Fifth Circuit has reversed the discovery order in this case, it remains possible for Xiaomi to file a new application for discovery in the future, should circumstances change. The court's ruling leaves the door open for further legal action, depending on developments in the ongoing patent infringement proceedings in the UPC.