The Third Circuit Court of Appeals has denied a petition from Mamdouh Hebishy, an Egyptian citizen, challenging a decision by the Board of Immigration Appeals (BIA) regarding his immigration status. This ruling affects Hebishy, who has been fighting against his removal from the United States since 2002, and highlights the complexities of immigration law, particularly concerning the reopening of cases based on claims of changed circumstances in a home country.

Hebishy entered the United States in 1992 on a visitor visa but overstayed his permitted time. This led to his being charged with removal by the former Immigration and Naturalization Service. An Immigration Judge found him removable and denied his applications for asylum and withholding of removal. The BIA affirmed this decision, and Hebishy has since made multiple attempts to reopen his case.

In 2003 and 2011, Hebishy filed motions to reopen his removal proceedings, both of which were rejected by the BIA. His third attempt came in 2024, where he argued that conditions for Coptic Christians in Egypt had materially changed, warranting a reopening of his case. However, the BIA found that his motion was both time-barred and number-barred, meaning he had exceeded the allowed time frame and the number of motions he could file. This led to his petition for review (PFR) to the Third Circuit, which was filed on November 12, 2026.

The court ruled that it lacked jurisdiction to review the BIA’s decision to deny Hebishy’s motion to reopen sua sponte, which means on its own accord. The court clarified that it could only review the BIA’s decision for abuse of discretion. The judges noted that they would overturn the BIA’s denial only if it was “arbitrary, irrational, or contrary to law.”

The court further explained that a motion to reopen must generally be filed within 90 days of the BIA’s final decision, and a party is limited to one motion. Since Hebishy's final removal order was issued in 2002, his third motion filed in 2024 was untimely. The BIA had determined that Hebishy did not provide sufficient evidence to demonstrate that conditions in Egypt had materially changed since his initial removal hearing.

The judges stated, “the BIA did not abuse its discretion in concluding that the evidence did not show a material change post-1998.” They emphasized that Hebishy failed to establish the exception to the time and number limits based on changed country conditions, which is a requirement under immigration law.

Hebishy also argued that the BIA erred by not reopening his case on its own initiative. However, the court pointed out that the BIA has broad discretion in deciding whether to reopen cases and that this discretion is generally not subject to judicial review. The judges noted, “Because the BIA retains unfettered discretion to decline to sua sponte reopen or reconsider a deportation proceeding, this court is without jurisdiction to review a decision declining to exercise such discretion.”

This ruling has significant implications for individuals in similar situations as Hebishy, who may find themselves unable to challenge removal orders due to strict procedural rules. It underscores the importance of timely filing motions and the challenges faced by immigrants seeking to remain in the United States based on claims of changed circumstances in their home countries.

Looking ahead, it is unclear if Hebishy will appeal this decision to a higher court. The court filing did not mention any related cases pending that could influence future rulings on similar immigration matters. However, this case serves as a reminder of the complexities and strict regulations surrounding immigration proceedings in the United States.