A Vermont court recently ruled in a landlord-tenant dispute between Steven Mitowski and Tracy Rose. The case, Mitowski v. Rose (docket number 25-cv-2166), centered on claims of unpaid rent and damages to a rental property. The court's decision affects both parties and clarifies expectations in residential lease agreements.

The case began when Mitowski sought to evict Rose from a residential property he owned in Proctor, Vermont. The dispute arose after Rose failed to make timely rent payments and allegedly breached the lease agreement. However, the court found that the eviction claim was dismissed earlier in February 2026, and the focus shifted to the merits of Mitowski's claims for unpaid rent and damages. The court held a hearing on March 23, 2026, where both parties presented their cases. Mitowski was represented by Attorney Francesca Bove, while Rose represented herself.

The court evaluated the credibility of both parties and their testimonies, noting that their statements were sometimes vague and unreliable. The court's findings were based on the evidence presented and the standard of a preponderance of the evidence. The case highlights the importance of clear communication and adherence to lease terms in landlord-tenant relationships.

According to the court's findings, Mitowski and Rose entered into a two-year residential lease on December 11, 2024, with a monthly rent of $2,400. The lease required Rose to pay a security deposit of the same amount, but both parties acknowledged that no deposit was made. The court noted that the property was not ready for occupancy on the agreed date, which led to complications regarding rent payments. Rose did not make a rental payment on December 20, 2024, as the property was not available until December 30, 2024, when she received the keys.

Initially, the landlord-tenant relationship was amicable, with Rose paying rent for several months. However, tensions escalated when Mitowski sent Rose a notice to quit on April 15, 2025, claiming material breaches of the lease. The notice cited Rose's failure to pay the security deposit and the last month's rent, as well as allowing unauthorized occupants in the property. The court found that there was insufficient evidence to support these claims, particularly regarding the security deposit and unauthorized occupants.

After the notice to quit, Rose provided a check dated May 1, 2025, for $2,400, which she labeled as a security deposit at Mitowski's request. The court determined that this check could serve as partial rent for May, as Rose had not officially surrendered possession of the property until June 21, 2025. The court ruled that Rose owed pro-rated rent for June, amounting to $1,680.

In its ruling, the court stated, "The evidence does not show that there was a sound basis for the Plaintiff to issue a Notice to Quit and or file a claim for possession when he did." This finding indicated that Mitowski's actions were not justified under the lease terms, and as a result, Rose was not liable for attorney fees associated with the eviction process.

Ultimately, the court awarded Mitowski a total of $3,348.99, which included $1,680 in unpaid rent and $1,668.99 for damages to the property. The damages included costs for repairs and other expenses incurred due to Rose's tenancy. The court also approved reasonable attorney fees of $2,552.00 and costs of $421.66 related to the successful claims.

This ruling has significant implications for both parties. For Mitowski, it confirms his right to recover unpaid rent and damages, while for Rose, it emphasizes the importance of understanding lease agreements and the consequences of failing to adhere to their terms. The case also serves as a reminder for landlords and tenants alike to maintain clear communication and documentation throughout the rental process.

Looking ahead, it is unclear whether Rose will appeal the court's decision. The court filing did not specify if there are any related cases pending. However, this ruling may set a precedent for similar landlord-tenant disputes in Vermont, particularly regarding the enforcement of lease terms and the responsibilities of both parties.