A Vermont court recently ruled in a small claims case involving a timber harvest dispute between Laura VanGuilder and Green Mountain Forestry LLC. The case, filed under docket number 26-SC-01226, addressed claims of property damage and disagreements over additional costs related to a timber harvesting project.
The court's decision impacts both parties, particularly VanGuilder, who sought compensation for damages and uncompleted work. The ruling emphasizes the importance of clear communication and agreements in contractual relationships, particularly in service industries like forestry.
Background
Laura VanGuilder, the plaintiff, owns a parcel of forested land in Dummerston, Vermont. In November 2025, she met with Robert “Steve” Hardy, the owner of Green Mountain Forestry LLC, to discuss a timber harvest project on her property. Hardy's business specializes in managing timber harvests, including hiring contractors for various tasks.
After their initial meeting, VanGuilder and Hardy signed a contract on February 13, 2026. The agreement outlined the responsibilities of Green Mountain Forestry, including marking trees for harvesting, managing contractors, and preparing reports on the timber sale. The contract also stipulated that Hardy's business would receive 25% of the gross stumpage revenue from the project.
The project included thinning trees, harvesting mature ones, and clearing an area for a yurt. However, disagreements arose over additional work and costs, leading to the court hearing held on September 1 and October 20, 2026.
The Ruling
The Vermont Superior Court ruled in favor of VanGuilder for a total of $650. This amount included $500 for damage to a shed roof caused by equipment during the timber harvest and $150 for uncompleted stump burning work. The court found that while VanGuilder had agreed to the burning of stumps for a fee of $3,000, not all stumps were burned as she had requested.
The court ruled, "Ms. VanGuilder has not met her burden of proof that this item was not agreed to." The judge noted that VanGuilder received benefits from the additional work done on her property.
Mary Miles Teachout, the presiding judge, concluded that Hardy's testimony was credible and that he reasonably relied on VanGuilder's statements during their discussions. The court also determined that VanGuilder did not provide sufficient evidence to support her claims for additional damages beyond the awarded amount.
Impact
This ruling serves as a reminder of the importance of clear communication and written agreements in business transactions. It highlights how verbal agreements can lead to misunderstandings and disputes if not documented properly. The decision may also influence how similar cases are handled in the future, as it reinforces the idea that parties must clearly define the scope of work and associated costs.
For individuals and businesses involved in contracts, particularly in service industries like forestry, this case underscores the necessity of maintaining detailed records and ensuring all parties are on the same page regarding project expectations. The ruling may also encourage more precise language in contracts to prevent future disputes.
What's Next
Details were not available in the court filing regarding whether either party plans to appeal the ruling. There are no related cases pending that were mentioned in the opinion.
Read Next
Vermont court rules in favor of roofing company in payment dispute
Vermont Court Dismisses Lawsuit Against Fire District Board
Court rules Nature Conservancy can reclaim land from Stratton
Vermont court rules on landlord-tenant dispute over rent
Vermont Court Denies Interlocutory Appeal in Emilius Case
Vermont court strikes risk containment designation for inmate










