In a recent decision, the Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York ruled against Corning Incorporated in its attempt to secure insurance coverage from National Union Fire Insurance Company of Pittsburgh, PA. The court's ruling, dated November 17, 2026, confirmed that Corning's claim for defense and indemnity coverage was not valid due to the nature of the alleged damages. This ruling is significant as it clarifies the limitations of liability insurance in cases involving faulty workmanship.
The case, Corning Inc. v. National Union Fire Ins. Co. of Pittsburgh, PA, stems from a dispute over Corning's failure to deliver properly functioning distributed antenna systems (DAS) for a football stadium. The outcome of this case affects not only Corning but also other companies that might rely on similar insurance policies for coverage against claims of defective work. The court's decision emphasizes the importance of understanding the terms and exclusions within liability insurance policies.
Corning Incorporated, a major player in the technology and manufacturing sectors, initiated this declaratory judgment action after it encountered issues with the DAS it provided for a stadium. The company sought coverage from National Union Fire Insurance Company, arguing that the damages incurred were covered under its liability policy. The case was filed under Index No. 652298/22, Appeal No. 7517, and Case No. 2025-03561.
The dispute escalated to the appellate court after the Supreme Court of New York County dismissed Corning's complaint on May 1, 2025. The lower court had previously denied Corning's motion for partial summary judgment while granting National Union's motion for summary judgment, effectively dismissing Corning's claims. The case then moved to the appellate level for review.
In its ruling, the appellate court unanimously affirmed the lower court's decision. The judges noted that Corning's actions in designing and delivering a faulty DAS did not constitute a covered "occurrence" under the liability policy. The court stated, "the motion court correctly determined that plaintiff's actions of designing and delivering a faulty DAS, was not a covered 'occurrence' as contemplated by defendant's liability policy." This statement underscores the court's position that the nature of the alleged damages fell outside the scope of the insurance coverage.
The court further explained that while the policy could apply if Corning's faulty workmanship caused property damage to something other than its own work product, Corning failed to demonstrate any such damage. The judges referenced the testimony of Corning's vice president, who claimed damages occurred during the de-installation and re-installation process. However, the court found this testimony lacked corroborating evidence and was therefore insufficient to support Corning's claims.
Moreover, the court upheld National Union's disclaimer of coverage under Exclusion D of the policy. This exclusion specifies that there is no coverage for "impaired property," which is defined as tangible property that cannot be used or is less useful because it incorporates a product or work that is known to be defective. The court concluded that the DAS and the stadium itself were considered "tangible property" and that Corning did not own either. The court stated, "the physical DAS and stadium are considered 'tangible property.' Moreover, plaintiff did not own either, they were damaged after incorporating plaintiff's deficient DAS design." This ruling highlights the importance of ownership and responsibility in determining insurance coverage.
Corning's argument that the Professional Liability Exclusion should provide coverage was also rejected by the court. The judges pointed out that an exclusion from insurance coverage cannot create coverage. This clarification is vital for businesses to understand when navigating their insurance policies and coverage options.
The ruling has significant implications for the future of liability insurance claims in similar contexts. Companies like Corning, which rely on complex systems and installations, must be aware of the limitations of their insurance policies. This case serves as a reminder that not all damages or failures will be covered, especially if they result from the company's own work.
Moving forward, businesses in the technology and construction sectors may need to reassess their insurance policies to ensure they understand the exclusions and limitations that may apply. The ruling could also influence how insurance companies draft their policies and the language they use to define coverage and exclusions.
As for what’s next, it is unclear whether Corning plans to appeal the ruling. The court's decision is final unless a higher court chooses to review the case. Currently, there are no related cases pending that could impact this decision, but it may prompt other companies to evaluate their own insurance claims and policies in light of this ruling.
Read Next
New York court dismisses claims against law firms in estate case
Court denies F.J.H. Realty's request against Loft Board
Court affirms dismissal of discrimination case against employer
Ninth Circuit upholds labor arbitration ruling in Oregon case
Florida Court Dismisses Appeal in Property Dispute Case
Court rules on Cardinal Midstream v. Energy Transfer case










