The Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York has ruled in favor of Mikhail Vasilyvich Klyukin and others, affirming a lower court's decision to deny a motion by D&V Realty LLC to disqualify the law firm Nelson Mullins Riley Scarborough LLP (NMRS) from representing the defendants. This ruling, made on November 17, 2026, is significant as it addresses the complexities of attorney-client relationships and the timing of disqualification motions.
The case, identified by Index No. 656782/22 and Appeal No. 7511, stems from a dispute involving D&V Realty LLC and Klyukin, among others. The plaintiffs sought to disqualify NMRS based on alleged conflicts of interest. However, the court found that D&V Realty had delayed their motion for disqualification, which ultimately influenced the court's decision.
In the initial ruling, the Supreme Court of New York County, presided over by Justice Joel M. Cohen, determined that the plaintiffs did not meet the necessary burden of proof to justify disqualifying NMRS. The court emphasized that the plaintiffs' delay in seeking disqualification raised concerns about the strategic nature of their motion. This decision was later affirmed by the Appellate Division.
The parties involved in this case are D&V Realty LLC, the plaintiffs, and Mikhail Vasilyvich Klyukin, along with other defendants. The dispute revolves around the representation of the defendants by NMRS, which the plaintiffs argued presented a conflict of interest. The case reached the appellate court after the lower court denied the plaintiffs' motion to disqualify the law firm.
The court's ruling highlighted that the plaintiffs had failed to act promptly regarding their concerns about NMRS's representation. The court noted, “the purported conflict became apparent in November 2023, but plaintiffs did not demand that NMRS resign based on the conflict until February 2024.” This significant delay, lasting nearly two years, led the court to conclude that the motion for disqualification was likely strategic rather than based on genuine concern for ethical violations.
Furthermore, the court pointed out that disqualifying NMRS at such a late stage in the litigation could cause prejudice to the defendants. The court stated, “Disqualifying NMRS at such a late stage in the litigation would likely prejudice defendants.” This reasoning underlines the importance of timely action in legal proceedings, especially when it comes to matters of attorney representation.
The ruling serves as a reminder of the critical nature of timing in legal disputes, particularly in disqualification motions. The court's decision reinforces the principle that parties must act promptly when they believe there is a conflict of interest. Failure to do so can result in the loss of the ability to challenge an attorney's representation, as seen in this case.
The impact of this ruling extends beyond the immediate parties involved. It sets a precedent regarding the necessity of timely action in disqualification motions and highlights the importance of maintaining the integrity of the legal process. Attorneys and clients alike must be aware that delays in raising concerns about conflicts of interest can undermine their positions in court.
Going forward, this ruling may influence how similar cases are handled in New York and potentially beyond. Legal practitioners will likely take note of the court's emphasis on the need for prompt action in disqualification matters. This case could serve as a reference point for future disputes involving attorney-client relationships and the timing of legal motions.
As for the next steps, it remains to be seen whether D&V Realty will seek further appeal options. The court filing did not provide details on any potential related cases or future actions. However, the ruling leaves open the possibility for the plaintiffs to explore other legal avenues in their ongoing dispute with the defendants.
Read Next
New York court dismisses claims against law firms in estate case
Court denies F.J.H. Realty's request against Loft Board
Court upholds arbitration ruling in diamond sale dispute
Vermont court denies motion to amend wrongful death complaint
Vermont court dismisses eviction case against Catherine Morrill
Vermont court rules on timber harvest dispute case









