The California Court of Appeal recently issued a ruling in the case of Moffett v. Lake Merritt Healthcare Center, LLC, affirming in part and reversing in part a lower court's decision regarding arbitration agreements. The case centers on Paris D'Marco Moffett, who was shot and paralyzed before ultimately being killed while at a nursing facility. The ruling has implications for how arbitration agreements are enforced in wrongful death and negligence claims.
In this case, Paris Moffett was admitted to Lake Merritt Healthcare Center (LMHC) after being shot in September 2022. While at the facility, he signed an arbitration agreement, but his father, Paris D'Marco Moffett, did not. Following another shooting incident that led to Paris's death, the elder Moffett filed a lawsuit against LMHC and its owner, Crystal Solorzano, alleging negligence and wrongful death. The trial court denied the defendants' motion to compel arbitration, leading to the appeal.
Background
Paris D'Marco Moffett was a young man who suffered a life-changing injury when he was shot and paralyzed in September 2022. He was later admitted to LMHC, where he signed an arbitration agreement in March 2023. This agreement stated that it would be binding on all parties, including family members and heirs. However, his father, Moffett, did not sign this agreement.
Tragically, just days after signing the arbitration agreement, Paris was fatally shot by intruders at the nursing facility. Following his death, Moffett filed a lawsuit against LMHC and Solorzano, claiming negligence, negligent abuse of a dependent adult, and wrongful death. The defendants sought to compel arbitration based on the agreement signed by Paris, but the trial court denied their motion, primarily because Moffett had not signed the agreement.
The Ruling
The Court of Appeal ruled on the matter, affirming the trial court's decision regarding the wrongful death claim but reversing it concerning the other claims. The court stated, "As a general rule, plaintiffs cannot be compelled to arbitrate their disputes if they have not previously agreed to arbitration." This ruling emphasizes that Moffett, as a non-signatory, could not be compelled to arbitrate the wrongful death claim.
However, the court found that the remaining claims—negligence, negligent abuse of a dependent adult, and damages for pain and suffering—were survivor claims. The court noted that these claims belonged to Paris before his death and survived through Moffett as his successor in interest. The court stated, "A survivor cause of action is not a new cause of action that vests in the heirs on the death of the decedent. It is instead a separate and distinct cause of action which belonged to the decedent before death but, by statute, survives that event." Therefore, the court concluded that Moffett was bound to arbitrate these claims.
Impact
This ruling has significant implications for future cases involving arbitration agreements, especially in wrongful death and negligence claims. It clarifies that non-signatories cannot be compelled to arbitrate claims unless they have signed the agreement themselves. However, it also establishes that survivor claims, which arise from the decedent's injuries, may be subject to arbitration if the decedent had signed an arbitration agreement.
The decision reinforces the importance of understanding the nature of claims in relation to arbitration agreements. It differentiates between wrongful death claims, which are independent and cannot be arbitrated by non-signatories, and survivor claims, which may be arbitrated if the deceased party had agreed to arbitration.
What's Next
The defendants may seek further legal options following this ruling, including potentially appealing the decision to a higher court. As of now, there are no related cases pending that directly connect to this ruling.
Read Next
Court affirms murder conviction of Deshawn Wallace
California court remands case for resentencing under new law
California Court upholds termination of parental rights in ICWA case
Oregon Court Reverses Trust Judgment Amid Family Dispute
Oregon court upholds $500 contempt sanction in McElroy case
Oregon Court Rules on Stalking Protective Order Appeal










