The Oregon Court of Appeals has issued a ruling regarding a stalking protective order (SPO) that affects Kip Pierce, the defendant, who has been trying to terminate the order since it was issued in 2012. The court's decision allows for further proceedings to determine if the order should be lifted, which is significant for Pierce as it could impact his legal standing and personal freedom.

This case, known as L. B. v. Pierce, was filed under docket number A187275. The court's ruling, delivered on November 18, 2026, by Presiding Judge Shorr, addresses the ongoing dispute over the validity and necessity of the SPO that has been in place for over a decade. The ruling is particularly important as it opens the door for Pierce to present new evidence regarding the circumstances surrounding the original order.

Background

The parties involved in this case are L. B., the petitioner who sought the stalking protective order, and Kip Pierce, the respondent who is appealing the order. The SPO was initially granted in 2012 after Pierce failed to appear at the hearing. Since then, Pierce has made multiple attempts to set aside or vacate the order, all of which have been denied by the trial court.

In 2023 alone, Pierce filed at least five motions to challenge the SPO, with many of these motions repeating arguments that had been previously rejected. The trial court noted that Pierce's claims often centered around the lack of evidence presented at the 2012 hearing, issues of service, and assertions that he had not been properly informed about the necessity of his appearance. However, these arguments did not succeed in convincing the court to lift the order.

The Ruling

The Court of Appeals ruled that the trial court had erred in denying Pierce's motion to terminate the SPO based on the changes in circumstances since its issuance. The court stated, "We have concluded that once an SPO has been entered, it may later be terminated if, on respondent’s motion, the court finds that the criteria for issuing the order... are no longer present." This ruling allows for the possibility that the order could be lifted if Pierce can demonstrate that the conditions warranting the SPO are no longer applicable.

Judge Shorr emphasized that the trial court incorrectly characterized the SPO as a permanent order that could not be terminated. The court noted that the trial court's conclusion that Pierce was "stuck with a permanent stalking order for life" was a misinterpretation of the law. The ruling vacated the previous order in part, affirming the denial of the request to set aside the SPO based on the original hearing but allowing for a review of the evidence regarding its termination.

Impact

This ruling has significant implications for Kip Pierce, as it provides him with an opportunity to present new evidence regarding his situation and the lack of contact with L. B. over the years. The court's decision to remand the case for further proceedings means that Pierce can argue that the conditions for the SPO are no longer present, which could lead to the order being lifted.

The ruling also highlights the importance of judicial review in cases involving protective orders. It emphasizes that while courts must consider past decisions, they also have a duty to evaluate any new evidence presented that may affect the necessity of such orders. This case could set a precedent for how courts handle similar requests in the future, particularly in terms of recognizing changes in circumstances over time.

What's Next

The case is now remanded to the lower court for further proceedings, where the trial court will consider whether the criteria for the SPO are still valid based on new evidence. It remains to be seen if Pierce will successfully demonstrate that the order should be terminated. There is no indication in the court filing that this ruling can be appealed further, but it does open the door for a potential reassessment of the circumstances surrounding the original protective order.