The Third Circuit Court of Appeals has vacated a lower court's decision that denied Dontae Devero's request to modify his supervised release conditions to allow marijuana use for religious purposes. The ruling, issued on November 18, 2026, is significant as it emphasizes the need for courts to properly evaluate religious freedom claims under the Religious Freedom Restoration Act (RFRA).
Devero, who is a practicing Rastafarian, argued that the prohibition on marijuana use substantially burdened his religious practices. The case highlights the intersection of drug regulations and religious freedoms, impacting individuals who seek to practice their faith while under legal supervision.
Background
Dontae Devero was sentenced in May 2013 after pleading guilty to conspiracy to distribute cocaine base. He received a ten-year prison sentence followed by eight years of supervised release. Devero began his supervised release in October 2022, and in November 2023, his supervision was transferred to the Western District of Pennsylvania.
In September 2024, Devero filed a motion requesting to modify the conditions of his supervised release to permit the use of marijuana during Rastafarian religious ceremonies. He claimed that the restrictions on marijuana use violated his right to the free exercise of his religion, as protected by the RFRA. The RFRA prohibits the government from imposing a substantial burden on an individual's exercise of religion unless it can demonstrate that the burden serves a compelling government interest in the least restrictive manner.
The Ruling
The District Court denied Devero's motion in a brief opinion, stating that it assumed his desire for religious observation was sincere. However, the court noted that the majority of case law did not support Devero's position, suggesting that similar requests had been rejected in the past.
The Third Circuit, led by Circuit Judge Roth, found that the District Court had failed to apply the RFRA framework correctly. The court stated, "To establish a prima facie case under the RFRA, Devero must allege that 'the government (1) substantially burdened (2) a sincere (3) religious exercise.'" The court emphasized that the lower court needed to consider Devero's specific circumstances rather than rely on previous cases with different contexts.
Impact
This ruling could have significant implications for individuals seeking to practice their religious beliefs while under supervision. By vacating the lower court's decision, the Third Circuit has reinforced the importance of evaluating religious freedom claims properly. The case underscores that courts must consider the specific details of each claim rather than relying solely on past rulings.
The ruling may also encourage other individuals in similar situations to assert their rights under the RFRA. If the District Court ultimately finds in favor of Devero, it could set a precedent for allowing religious exemptions to drug use restrictions, particularly for individuals who can demonstrate a sincere religious belief.
What's Next
The District Court is now tasked with reevaluating Devero's request under the RFRA framework. It remains to be seen whether the court will grant Devero's request to use marijuana for religious purposes or uphold the existing restrictions. There is no indication that this case will be appealed further at this stage.
Read Next
Court denies Catherine Wakefield's mandamus petition
Third Circuit reverses suppression order in child abuse case
Court denies rehearing in church zoning dispute case
Oregon Court Affirms Conviction of Ricki Scott Collin
Oregon court upholds conviction in sexual abuse case
Oregon Court upholds juvenile delinquency ruling in assault case










