The Oregon Court of Appeals recently issued a ruling in the case of Marliave v. Duncan, which involved a business dispute between two couples and their respective companies. The court's decision, filed on November 18, 2026, addresses several legal issues, including the award of attorney fees and the management of trial proceedings. This ruling affects the plaintiffs, David and Emma Marliave and Christopher and Monee Johnston, as well as the defendants, Iain and Tonya Duncan and their company, Duncan Culinary Ventures, Inc.

The case arose from a complex business relationship between the parties, which included shared ownership of two limited liability companies, DK3, LLC and S&J Corvallis, LLC. The plaintiffs accused the defendants of breaching their operating agreements and mismanaging the companies, leading to financial losses. The trial court ruled in favor of the plaintiffs, awarding them $532,000 plus interest, attorney fees, and costs. The defendants appealed the judgment, raising several issues regarding the trial court's decisions.

The Court of Appeals reviewed the case and ultimately reversed the trial court's award of attorney fees to the plaintiffs while affirming the remainder of the judgment. The court found that the trial court had not abused its discretion in managing the trial proceedings, including limiting the presentation of evidence due to time constraints. The court stated, "Defendants were able to complete cross-examination and present a significant portion of their case in chief," indicating that the trial court's actions did not hinder the defendants' ability to present their case effectively.

In their appeal, the defendants argued that the trial court had made several errors, including improperly limiting their ability to present evidence and denying their motion to disqualify the trial judge. The court found that the trial judge had acted within her rights and that the defendants had not followed the proper procedures for disqualification. The court also upheld the trial court's decision to deny the defendants' motion to postpone the trial, which was based on the late disclosure of evidence.

One of the key issues in the appeal was the award of attorney fees to the plaintiffs. The defendants contended that the operating agreements between the parties only allowed for attorney fees related to arbitration, not litigation. The Court of Appeals agreed, stating, "A contract that provides for attorney fees for arbitration does not unambiguously provide for an award of attorney fees for litigation." As a result, the court reversed the portion of the judgment requiring the defendants to pay the plaintiffs' attorney fees.

The court also addressed the trial court's decision to impose sanctions on the defendants for their late disclosure of evidence. While the defendants did not challenge this aspect of the ruling, they argued that the amount of attorney fees awarded as a sanction was excessive. The Court of Appeals upheld the trial court's discretion in determining the appropriate amount of fees, stating that the fees were reasonably related to the sanctionable conduct.

This ruling has significant implications for the parties involved, particularly regarding the financial responsibilities stemming from the lawsuit. The reversal of the attorney fees award means that the plaintiffs will not receive the additional financial compensation they sought from the defendants. The decision also clarifies the limitations of attorney fee provisions in business contracts, emphasizing that such provisions may not extend to litigation if they specifically pertain to arbitration.

Looking ahead, the parties may consider their options following this ruling. While the defendants have won a partial victory with the reversal of attorney fees, the plaintiffs may seek further legal recourse or clarification on other aspects of the judgment. The court's ruling does not appear to leave room for an appeal to a higher court, as it is a memorandum opinion and not a precedent-setting decision.

In conclusion, the Oregon Court of Appeals' ruling in Marliave v. Duncan highlights the complexities of business disputes and the importance of clear contractual agreements. As the parties navigate the aftermath of this decision, they will need to address the financial implications and consider their next steps in this ongoing legal matter.