The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals ruled against Reyna Mendez-De Vasquez and her children, denying their petition for asylum. This decision affects the family’s ability to remain in the United States and highlights the challenges many face when seeking refuge from violence in their home countries. The ruling was issued on November 18, 2026, under docket number 20-70898.
Mendez-De Vasquez, a native of El Salvador, and her children sought asylum in the U.S. due to threats and extortion from gangs in their home country. They argued that their lives were in danger and that they deserved protection under U.S. immigration law. However, the court found that their claims did not sufficiently demonstrate a connection to a protected ground, such as membership in a particular social group.
The case began when Mendez-De Vasquez and her children applied for asylum, withholding of removal, and protection under the Convention Against Torture (CAT) after facing threats from gangs in El Salvador. The family claimed that they were targeted for extortion, which they believed was a valid reason for their asylum request. Their case was initially heard by an Immigration Judge (IJ), who denied their application. The family then appealed to the Board of Immigration Appeals (BIA), which upheld the IJ's decision.
The BIA's ruling was based on the family’s failure to establish a necessary connection between the persecution they faced and a protected ground. The court emphasized that Mendez-De Vasquez did not adequately challenge the BIA's findings regarding nexus and acquiescence, which are crucial elements in asylum cases. The court stated, "Petitioners have failed to challenge the agency’s nexus and acquiescence determinations and have therefore waived these arguments." This means that the family could not argue that the threats they faced were due to their status as members of a particular social group, which is a requirement for asylum.
The court also noted that even if the family had presented their arguments correctly, there was substantial evidence to support the BIA's conclusion that there was no nexus to a protected ground. The court explained, "Substantial evidence therefore supports the agency’s conclusion that Petitioners have failed to establish nexus and are ineligible for asylum and withholding of removal." This indicates that the court found the evidence provided by the family did not meet the legal standards required for asylum.
Furthermore, the court addressed the family’s claim for relief under the Convention Against Torture. To qualify for CAT protection, applicants must demonstrate that they would likely be tortured if returned to their home country, and that such torture would occur with the consent or acquiescence of a public official. The court found that the family did not provide sufficient evidence to support this claim, stating, "Petitioners have not provided any evidence indicating that any alleged harm would be conducted 'with the consent or acquiescence of a public official.'" This ruling underscores the high burden of proof required for applicants seeking protection under CAT.
The court's decision has significant implications for Mendez-De Vasquez and her children, as it denies them the opportunity to remain in the United States. This case reflects the broader challenges faced by many asylum seekers, particularly those fleeing violence in Central America. The ruling may also affect other families in similar situations, as it sets a precedent regarding the necessity of demonstrating a clear connection to a protected ground in asylum claims.
Looking ahead, the family may explore the possibility of appealing the decision to a higher court, although the chances of success in such appeals can vary. The court filing did not indicate whether there are any related cases pending that could influence this situation. However, the outcome of this case will likely resonate with other asylum seekers facing similar challenges in the Ninth Circuit and beyond.
















