The Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania has affirmed a decision denying Carlos Ng, Jr.'s request for documents related to a noncriminal investigation into his father's medical care. The court ruled that the requested records were exempt from disclosure under the Right-to-Know Law (RTKL) due to confidentiality protections. This ruling impacts individuals seeking access to similar records in Pennsylvania.

The case, titled C. Ng v. Dept. of State (OOR), was filed under docket number 1498 C.D. 2025. The decision, made by Judge Christine Fizzano Cannon, was issued on November 18, 2026. Ng's request was initially denied by the Pennsylvania Department of State's Office of Open Records (OOR), which stated that the documents were part of a noncriminal investigation and therefore not subject to public disclosure.

Background

Carlos Ng, Jr. filed a complaint against four medical licensees after his father's death in a hospital. The Pennsylvania Department of State chose not to prosecute the complaint. Following this decision, Ng submitted a request for records related to his father's medical investigation on August 29, 2025. He sought both a report of the investigation and forensic findings from the medical records.

The Department partially granted Ng's request, providing a closing letter regarding his complaint but withholding other records, citing the noncriminal investigatory exemption under Section 708(b)(17) of the RTKL. Ng appealed this decision to the OOR on September 4, 2025, arguing that the withheld documents were necessary for managing his father's estate.

The Ruling

The OOR denied Ng's appeal on October 21, 2025, upholding the Department's decision to withhold the records. Ng subsequently appealed to the Commonwealth Court. The court found that Ng had waived his issues on appeal because he failed to develop any arguments in accordance with the Pennsylvania Rules of Appellate Procedure.

Judge Fizzano Cannon noted, "Petitioner fails to include an argument section in his brief," emphasizing that the court cannot create arguments for a party. The court also highlighted that Ng's assertions did not provide sufficient legal authority or a meaningful basis for review. Consequently, the court affirmed the OOR's determination that the records were exempt from disclosure.

Impact

This ruling has significant implications for individuals seeking access to records related to noncriminal investigations in Pennsylvania. The court's decision reinforces the confidentiality protections afforded to records associated with licensure-related complaints and investigations. It clarifies that individuals must provide substantial arguments and legal citations when appealing decisions regarding public records requests.

Moreover, the ruling underscores the importance of adhering to procedural rules when filing appeals. Pro se litigants, like Ng, are subject to the same standards as represented parties, which means they must adequately present their cases to the court.

What's Next

Ng's options for further appeal are limited, as the Commonwealth Court's ruling is typically final in such cases unless there are grounds for further review by the Pennsylvania Supreme Court. There are no related cases pending that would impact this decision.