The Wisconsin Court of Appeals recently upheld a lower court's decision to evict JJ Briggs Consulting, LLC from a commercial property. This ruling came after a dispute over the terms of a lease agreement and the responsibilities of both parties regarding occupancy permits. The case, titled Mr. Storage, LLC v. JJ Briggs Consulting, LLC (2026AP001057), highlights the complexities involved in commercial leasing and the importance of adhering to contractual obligations.
The court's decision affects JJ Briggs Consulting and its owner, Jamie Briggs, who claimed that the property was not suitable for its intended use due to safety deficiencies. The outcome is significant as it clarifies the responsibilities of landlords and tenants in commercial leases, particularly regarding occupancy permits and conditions of the leased premises.
Background
Jamie Briggs entered into a year-long lease agreement with Mr. Storage, LLC to rent a warehouse space for her business. The lease commenced on January 15, 2026, and was set to run until January 14, 2027. The lease specified that the premises would be used for an insurance company office and studio art space. However, after a city inspection, it was determined that the property did not meet safety requirements, including the need for exit signage and independent egress.
Due to these issues, Jamie Briggs did not pay the full rent, claiming she could not operate her business as intended. In response, Mr. Storage initiated an eviction lawsuit. Jamie filed a counterclaim, arguing that the leased premises were not suitable for occupancy and sought damages for her losses. The case was brought before the Fond du Lac County Circuit Court, where a bench trial was held to resolve the dispute.
The Ruling
After hearing testimony from both parties, the circuit court found in favor of Mr. Storage, ruling that Jamie Briggs had materially breached the lease by failing to pay rent. The court determined that the lease was clear and unambiguous, stating that there was no obligation for Mr. Storage to ensure the property met occupancy permit requirements. The court noted, "No where in the terms of the lease is there assignment of responsibility, such that the occupancy permit would be the responsibility of [Mr. Storage]."
The court also found that Jamie's counterclaim lacked sufficient evidence to support her claims about the property's untenantability. It ruled that her failure to obtain an occupancy permit did not render the premises untenantable. Following the ruling, the court issued a writ of eviction against JJ Briggs Consulting.
Jamie Briggs later filed a motion for reconsideration, seeking clarification on her counterclaim and requesting the court to reconsider its ruling. However, the court denied this motion, reaffirming its previous findings and stating that credible evidence demonstrated a material breach due to Jamie's failure to pay rent.
Impact
The court's ruling sets a precedent regarding the responsibilities of landlords and tenants in commercial leases, particularly concerning occupancy permits and the conditions of the leased premises. It clarifies that landlords may not be held responsible for ensuring that a property meets all safety codes unless explicitly stated in the lease agreement. This decision emphasizes the importance of carefully reviewing lease terms and understanding the obligations of each party.
For JJ Briggs Consulting, the ruling means that the eviction stands, and the business will need to find alternative arrangements. The case serves as a reminder for business owners to ensure that leased properties meet all legal requirements before signing a lease and committing to a business plan.
What's Next
While the decision can be appealed, details about any potential appeal were not available in the court filing. Jamie Briggs has the option to seek further review from the Wisconsin Supreme Court, but it remains unclear if she will pursue this route. There are no related cases pending that were mentioned in the court's opinion.
Read Next
Wisconsin court affirms homicide conviction of Travarus Pierce
Court affirms speeding conviction of Ali J. Yousef
Wisconsin court denies tribal intervention in property case
Court affirms denial of records request in Ng v. Dept. of State
Oregon Court Reverses Trust Judgment Amid Family Dispute
Oregon court upholds $500 contempt sanction in McElroy case










