The Pennsylvania Commonwealth Court upheld a decision denying Carlos Ng, Jr.'s request for forensic medical records related to his father's death. This ruling affects individuals seeking access to records under the Right-to-Know Law (RTKL) in cases involving noncriminal investigations.
On November 18, 2026, the court ruled on the case of C. Ng v. Dept. of State (OOR), docket number 1498 C.D. 2025. The court's decision is significant as it clarifies the boundaries of public access to records that pertain to noncriminal investigations, particularly in the context of medical licensure complaints.
Background
Carlos Ng, Jr. filed a complaint with the Pennsylvania Department of State after the death of his father in a hospital. Ng's complaint was directed against four medical licensees, but the Department chose not to prosecute the case. Following this, Ng submitted a request under the RTKL on August 29, 2025, seeking access to documents related to his father's medical investigation, including a forensic report.
The Department of State partially granted Ng's request by providing a closing letter regarding his complaint but withheld other records citing the noncriminal investigatory exemption under the RTKL. Ng appealed this decision to the Office of Open Records (OOR) on September 4, 2025, arguing that the withheld documents were necessary for managing his father's estate.
The OOR reviewed the case and determined that the requested records were exempt from disclosure under Section 708(b)(17) of the RTKL, which protects records related to noncriminal investigations. Ng subsequently filed an appeal with the Commonwealth Court.
The Ruling
The Commonwealth Court, led by Judge Christine Fizzano Cannon, affirmed the OOR's decision, stating that Ng had waived all issues on appeal due to his failure to adequately develop his arguments. The court noted, "Petitioner fails to raise or develop any issues in an argument section of his brief." This ruling emphasizes the importance of following procedural rules in legal appeals.
In its opinion, the court highlighted that Ng's brief contained insufficient discussion and did not cite relevant legal authority, which led to the conclusion that he had waived his claims. The court stated, "This Court cannot consider material attached to a brief, as such material is not part of the record before us." Even if Ng had not waived his issues, the court indicated that the OOR's determination was still valid based on the merits of the case.
Impact
This ruling has implications for individuals seeking public records under the RTKL, particularly in cases involving noncriminal investigations. It underscores the necessity for requesters to provide well-developed arguments and adhere to procedural requirements when appealing decisions regarding record access.
The decision reinforces the confidentiality of records related to noncriminal investigations, especially those concerning medical licensure complaints. This may limit access to sensitive information for individuals involved in similar situations, as the court upheld the Department's assertion that such records are confidential and privileged by law.
What's Next
Ng may consider appealing the court's decision, but the ruling sets a precedent regarding the necessity of following procedural rules in appeals. There are no indications of related cases pending that would impact this decision.
Read Next
Pennsylvania Court Upholds Conviction of Tyrone C. Mason
Court rules on Cardinal Midstream v. Energy Transfer case
Pennsylvania court remands appeal for further proceedings
Oregon Court Reverses Trust Judgment Amid Family Dispute
Oregon court upholds $500 contempt sanction in McElroy case
Oregon Court Rules on Stalking Protective Order Appeal










