A recent ruling from the District Court for the District of Columbia has significant implications for employment discrimination cases, particularly those involving pregnancy. The court addressed the case of Bathsheba N. Hodge against Fady Saba and others, stemming from allegations of discrimination and retaliation related to Hodge's pregnancy while employed at L’Avant-Garde, a French restaurant in Washington, D.C.
The court's decision, issued on November 18, 2026, came after Hodge filed a lawsuit claiming unlawful discrimination, retaliation, and harassment under both federal and District of Columbia law. The ruling is critical as it highlights the legal protections for pregnant employees and the responsibilities of employers in such situations.
Hodge began her employment at L’Avant-Garde in January 2023. In June of that year, she discovered she was pregnant. Following her announcement to management, she reported experiencing mistreatment from one of her managers, Samuel Holley. After raising her concerns, Hodge alleged that management retaliated against her, which led to her termination. The case, identified as Civil Action No. 2024-2247, was brought before Magistrate Judge Matthew J. Sharbaugh.
The dispute centers on Hodge's claims of discrimination and retaliation. She alleged that after informing her employer about her pregnancy, she faced harassment and was ultimately terminated. The case progressed through the court system, leading to a motion for summary judgment by the defendants, who sought to dismiss Hodge's claims.
In the ruling, the court addressed each of Hodge's claims. The court found that Hodge's claims under the Protecting Pregnant Workers Fairness Act (PPWFA) and her hostile work environment claim were not supported by sufficient evidence. Specifically, the court stated, "Hodge’s claim under D.C.’s Protecting Pregnant Workers Fairness Act and her hostile-work-environment claim fail as a matter of law and undisputed fact." However, the court denied the defendants' motion for summary judgment on Hodge's other claims of discrimination and retaliation, indicating that there were genuine disputes of material fact that warranted further examination.
Judge Sharbaugh emphasized that Hodge's claims of gender discrimination under the D.C. Human Rights Act (DCHRA) and her Title VII claims based on sex and pregnancy discrimination would proceed. The court ruled that Hodge had presented enough evidence to suggest that she may have faced adverse employment actions, including a potential termination or forced leave due to her pregnancy.
The ruling is significant not only for Hodge but also for other employees facing similar situations. It reinforces the idea that employers must be cautious in their treatment of pregnant employees and that claims of discrimination and retaliation must be taken seriously. The court's decision to allow some claims to proceed sets an important precedent for future cases involving pregnancy discrimination.
Moving forward, this case highlights the need for employers to ensure compliance with laws protecting pregnant workers. Employers are reminded of their obligations under both federal and local laws to provide reasonable accommodations and to refrain from retaliating against employees who assert their rights.
As for what’s next, the case will continue in court, allowing Hodge to present her claims of discrimination and retaliation. The defendants may also seek to appeal the court's decision regarding the claims that were not dismissed. The outcome of this case could influence how similar cases are handled in the future, particularly in the context of workplace discrimination against pregnant employees.
Read Next
Court dismisses immigration petition delay case against DHS
Court rules on negligence case against transit authority
Court Rules on FOIA Case Involving Federal Prisoner Cooper
Oregon court upholds sexual abuse protective order appeal
Seventh Circuit Court Reverses Dismissal of Illinois Law Case
Court upholds ruling against Fishman in disability case










