A recent ruling by the United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit affirmed a lower court's decision in the case of Fishman v. City of New Rochelle, No. 25-423. The court upheld the summary judgment granted in favor of the City of New Rochelle, which had been accused of violating the rights of Marc Fishman under the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) and the Rehabilitation Act (RA). This decision affects individuals with disabilities and raises questions about how police interact with disabled persons during custodial interviews.

Marc Fishman, who has cognitive and hearing disabilities, was arrested in December 2018 for violating an order of protection. He claimed that the New Rochelle Police Department (NRPD) denied him access to his disability aide and romantic partner, Isabel Bolivar, during his custodial interview. Fishman argued that this refusal constituted a violation of his rights under the ADA and RA.

The case began when Fishman was arrested after he allegedly violated a family court order that prohibited him from contacting his children. Following the arrest, Fishman filed a lawsuit against the City of New Rochelle, several police officials, and Westchester County, claiming discrimination based on his disabilities. The case was initially heard in the Southern District of New York, where the court ruled in favor of the City, prompting Fishman to appeal.

The dispute centers on whether Fishman requested reasonable accommodations during his police interview. Fishman contended that he asked to have Bolivar present to assist him, while the City argued that he did not make such a request and was coherent during the interview. The district court found that Fishman did not demonstrate that he was denied meaningful access to the services provided by the police.

In its ruling, the Second Circuit stated, "Even viewing the evidence in his favor—and assuming that Title II applies to police interrogations—Fishman received 'meaningful access' to those services to which he was 'legally entitled' under the ADA." The court emphasized that the officer involved, Lane Schlesinger, followed proper protocols and determined that there was probable cause for Fishman's arrest.

The court's opinion noted that Fishman's arguments regarding hypothetical scenarios where Bolivar's presence might have changed the outcome of the interview did not establish a legal basis for his claims. The ruling clarified that the ADA requires reasonable accommodation but does not guarantee a preference for disabled individuals in legal situations.

The court concluded that Fishman was not denied meaningful access to police services, affirming the lower court's decision to grant summary judgment in favor of the City. The ruling also indicated that Fishman's claims under the Rehabilitation Act failed for the same reasons as his ADA claims, as both statutes impose identical requirements.

This ruling is significant for individuals with disabilities, as it clarifies the standards for reasonable accommodations in police interactions. It highlights the importance of demonstrating that a denial of access is directly related to a disability. The decision may influence how police departments approach accommodations for individuals with disabilities during custodial procedures.

Going forward, this ruling may set a precedent for similar cases involving disability rights and police interactions. It emphasizes the need for clear communication and documentation of accommodation requests during police interviews. The outcome may also affect how law enforcement agencies train officers to handle situations involving individuals with disabilities.

As for the future of this case, it is unclear if Fishman will seek further legal recourse. The court's ruling can be appealed to the U.S. Supreme Court, but details regarding any potential appeal were not available in the court filing. There are currently no related cases pending that would directly impact this ruling.