In a recent ruling, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit upheld the dismissal of a privacy claim filed by James Hsieh against PitchBook Data, Inc. The court determined that Hsieh's claim was filed too late, falling outside the one-year statute of limitations set by Illinois law. This decision affects individuals who may seek to bring similar claims under the Illinois Right of Publicity Act.
The case, Hsieh v. PitchBook Data, Inc., was decided on November 18, 2026, and it underscores the importance of timely filing claims related to privacy and publicity rights. The ruling highlights the legal landscape surrounding privacy laws and the strict timelines that plaintiffs must adhere to when seeking redress.
Background
James Hsieh, a professional in the private equity and venture capital sectors, filed his lawsuit against PitchBook Data, Inc. after the company published his name, email, and job title on its website without his consent. PitchBook operates a database that provides information about professionals in these industries, and Hsieh alleged that the unauthorized use of his identity violated his rights under the Illinois Right of Publicity Act (IRPA).
Hsieh initially filed his claim in Illinois state court in October 2024, more than three years after PitchBook added his information to its database. The case was then moved to federal court after PitchBook invoked the Class Action Fairness Act, which allows for federal jurisdiction in certain class action cases. PitchBook argued that Hsieh's claim was untimely due to the one-year statute of limitations that applies to claims under the IRPA.
The Ruling
The Seventh Circuit, led by Judge Scudder, affirmed the district court's decision to dismiss Hsieh's claim. The court referenced its earlier ruling in Giovannelli v. Walmart Inc., which established that claims under the Illinois Right of Privacy Act are subject to a one-year statute of limitations. Judge Scudder noted, "Absent signals from the state courts or other developments that call into question an earlier Erie Railroad prediction, we leave our precedent undisturbed."
The court found that Hsieh's arguments did not provide sufficient evidence to warrant a change in the established interpretation of the statute of limitations. The district court had relied on the Illinois Appellate Court's reasoning in Blair v. Nevada Landing Partnership, which held that the one-year limitations period applies to claims under the IRPA. The Seventh Circuit reiterated that Illinois courts have consistently followed this precedent.
Impact
This ruling has significant implications for individuals seeking to file claims under the Illinois Right of Publicity Act. It reinforces the necessity for plaintiffs to be aware of the strict timelines associated with such claims. The court's decision may deter potential lawsuits from individuals who may not file their claims promptly, knowing that delays could result in dismissal.
Furthermore, the ruling solidifies the precedent established in previous cases regarding the application of the one-year statute of limitations to privacy claims in Illinois. This consistency in legal interpretation helps provide clarity for both plaintiffs and defendants in future cases involving publicity rights.
What's Next
Hsieh's options for appeal are limited, as the Seventh Circuit's ruling is final unless he seeks further review from the U.S. Supreme Court. There are currently no related cases pending that could directly influence this ruling.
Read Next
Court affirms jury's verdict in boiler lease dispute case
Court reverses dismissal of bakery's business license case
Court rules on copyright dispute over unpublished article
Court upholds ruling against Fishman in disability case
Court affirms ruling in disability discrimination case
Court reverses dismissal of privacy complaint against 5 Star Nutrition










