The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit has upheld disgorgement orders against two defendants, Joseph M. Laura and Anthony R. Sichenzio, for violating federal securities laws. The court's ruling, issued on November 18, 2026, affects both defendants, who are now required to repay significant amounts based on their illegal profits from fraudulent activities. This decision is important as it reinforces the Securities and Exchange Commission's (SEC) authority to impose financial penalties on those who violate securities laws.
The case, SEC v. Laura, was filed in the Eastern District of New York, where the district court had previously found Laura and Sichenzio civilly liable for their actions. The SEC sought disgorgement, which is a legal remedy requiring wrongdoers to give up profits obtained through illegal means. The amounts ordered for disgorgement were substantial: $3,431,860 for Laura and $1,629,369 for Sichenzio. The defendants argued that these amounts exceeded their actual net profits from the fraud, leading to their appeal.
Joseph M. Laura and Anthony R. Sichenzio were the main parties in this case. They faced allegations from the SEC regarding their involvement in a fraudulent scheme that misled investors. The SEC's actions are part of its broader mandate to protect investors and maintain fair and efficient markets. The case reached the Second Circuit after the district court imposed the disgorgement orders following consent judgments that found the defendants liable for their violations.
The court ruled that the district court's disgorgement calculations were reasonable and did not constitute an abuse of discretion. The judges noted, "The disgorgement amount must only be 'generally reasonable.'" They emphasized that the SEC only needed to provide a reasonable approximation of the profits related to the violations. The Second Circuit judges, Reena Raggi, Richard J. Sullivan, and Sarah A. L. Merriam, affirmed the lower court's decision, stating that the methods used to calculate the defendants' profits were within the permissible range of decisions.
In its ruling, the court explained how the district court calculated Laura's ill-gotten gains by summing investor funds transferred to his personal and law firm accounts, along with other financial activities. The court also noted that the defendants failed to provide sufficient evidence to justify deductions for business expenses, as they could not prove that the funds were used for legitimate business purposes. The judges found that the district court's methodology was sound and did not exceed its equitable power.
The ruling has significant implications for future cases involving securities fraud. It reinforces the SEC's ability to seek disgorgement for violations of securities laws and clarifies the standards for calculating such amounts. The decision indicates that courts will exercise wide latitude in determining disgorgement amounts, allowing for a reasonable approximation of profits tied to illegal activities.
Going forward, this ruling may influence how courts handle similar cases involving disgorgement. It emphasizes the importance of maintaining strict accountability for those who violate securities laws. The decision could deter potential fraudsters by highlighting the financial consequences of their actions. The ruling also underscores the SEC's commitment to protecting investors and ensuring that wrongdoers do not benefit from their illegal conduct.
While Laura and Sichenzio could potentially seek further legal action, details regarding any plans for appeal were not available in the court filing. The outcome of this case may also set a precedent for other ongoing or future cases involving securities fraud and disgorgement orders.
Read Next
Court affirms ruling in disability discrimination case
Court rules on involuntary commitment case in Rene v. Mustafa
Second Circuit upholds sentences in racketeering case
Ninth Circuit Reverses Driver Provider Ruling on Wage Claims
Louisiana Court Reverses Ruling in Oil Royalty Dispute
Court affirms Shreveport's approval of data center permit










