A New York appellate court has ruled against a plaintiff's request to combine two separate personal injury cases into one trial. The decision, made on November 18, 2026, affects Bernadetta Klimaszewska, who sought to join her claims against Judith Goldstein and Target Corporation. The ruling emphasizes the importance of distinct legal issues and procedural stages in personal injury litigation.

The court's decision comes from an appeal of an order issued by the Supreme Court of Kings County, which denied Klimaszewska's motion to join her two cases. This ruling is significant as it clarifies the standards for joining cases and the discretion courts have in managing trial proceedings.

Background

The case involves Bernadetta Klimaszewska, who is the appellant in this matter. She was involved in two separate incidents that led to her filing two personal injury lawsuits. The first incident occurred on November 10, 2018, when Klimaszewska was driving and collided with a vehicle owned by Judith Goldstein. The second incident took place earlier, on October 28, 2017, when a box fell on her from an overhead display at a Target store.

Klimaszewska filed her first lawsuit against Goldstein in September 2019 in Kings County, stemming from the car accident. Subsequently, in January 2020, she initiated a second lawsuit against Target in Queens County, related to the premises liability incident. The two cases were progressing through the legal system independently until Klimaszewska sought to combine them for trial.

The Ruling

The appellate court, in its ruling, affirmed the lower court's decision to deny Klimaszewska's motion to join the two cases. The judges emphasized that while joinder of cases is generally favored to avoid duplication of trials and reduce costs, it is not appropriate when the cases do not share significant common questions of law or fact.

The court ruled, "the Supreme Court providently exercised its discretion in denying the plaintiff's motion for a joint trial given the limited commonality between the distinct and unrelated actions, which involved disparate legal theories and dissimilar issues."

The judges noted that the two cases were at different procedural stages at the time of the motion, with the case against Goldstein ready for trial while discovery had not yet been completed in the case against Target.

Impact

This ruling has important implications for personal injury plaintiffs in New York. It clarifies that courts have broad discretion when deciding whether to allow the joining of cases for trial. The decision highlights that if cases involve different legal theories or issues, or if they are at different procedural stages, a court may deny a motion for joinder to prevent confusion and prejudice.

The ruling may discourage plaintiffs from attempting to combine unrelated cases, as the court's decision reinforces the need for clear connections between cases for them to be tried together. This could lead to more separate trials, which may increase legal costs for plaintiffs as they navigate multiple court proceedings.

What's Next

Details were not available in the court filing regarding whether Klimaszewska plans to appeal this decision. However, she still has her separate cases pending in their respective courts, which will continue to be litigated independently.