In a recent ruling, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit upheld a lower court's decision to award costs to Firelands Regional Medical Center (FRMC) after the dismissal of an employment discrimination lawsuit brought by Laura Obergefell. The court's decision, filed on November 17, 2026, confirms that the prevailing party in a lawsuit can recover certain costs, even when the losing party raises objections.
This ruling affects Obergefell, who worked as a nurse practitioner at FRMC, and the broader context of employment discrimination cases. It underscores the challenges plaintiffs face when pursuing such claims and the financial implications of losing a case.
Background
Laura Obergefell was employed as a nurse practitioner at the FRMC Wound Care Center located in Sandusky, Ohio. In her lawsuit, she alleged age discrimination against FRMC and several of its employees under both federal and state laws. After both parties filed motions for summary judgment, the district court ruled in favor of FRMC, stating that Obergefell did not provide adequate evidence to support her claims. This ruling was affirmed by the Sixth Circuit in January 2026.
Following the court's decision, FRMC filed a bill of costs amounting to $5,261.80, primarily for deposition transcripts. Obergefell contested this bill, arguing against the imposition of costs. However, after the appellate court upheld the summary judgment, the district court awarded the costs to FRMC, prompting Obergefell to appeal this decision.
The Ruling
The Sixth Circuit, comprised of Judges Stephanie Dawkins Davis, Kevin G. Ritz, and Whitney D. Hermandorfer, ruled in favor of FRMC, affirming the district court's award of costs. The court noted that under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 54(d)(1), costs are generally awarded to the prevailing party unless there is a compelling reason not to do so. The court stated, "Because costs are presumptively awarded, the losing party must make a substantial showing on appeal that the district court abused its discretion in awarding costs."
In its analysis, the court addressed several factors that could justify denying costs, including the complexity of the case and the potential chilling effect on future litigants. However, the court found that Obergefell's arguments did not meet the necessary threshold to overturn the district court's decision. The judges concluded, "We see no abuse of discretion on the part of the district court. We affirm the district court’s judgment and deny Obergefell’s motion to supplement the record."
Impact
This ruling has significant implications for future employment discrimination cases. It emphasizes that prevailing parties in litigation can expect to recover costs, which may deter some individuals from pursuing claims due to the financial risks involved. The court's decision also reinforces the notion that the financial status of the winning party, in this case, FRMC's substantial operating profits, should not influence the awarding of costs unless the losing party can demonstrate indigency.
Obergefell's case highlights the difficulties plaintiffs face when navigating the legal system, particularly in employment discrimination cases. The affirmation of the cost award may discourage potential plaintiffs from filing similar lawsuits, fearing the financial consequences of losing. The court's ruling may set a precedent that reinforces the financial burdens associated with litigation, particularly for individuals with limited resources.
What's Next
Obergefell has the option to appeal this ruling to the U.S. Supreme Court, although it is unclear if she will pursue that route. There are currently no related cases pending that directly address the same issues. As it stands, this ruling will likely influence how future employment discrimination cases are approached in the Sixth Circuit.
Read Next
Court upholds ruling in age discrimination case against school board
Court rules on police shooting case involving Casey Crowley
Sixth Circuit upholds jury verdict in Ford-InterMotive case
Vermont court denies motion to amend wrongful death complaint
Vermont court dismisses eviction case against Catherine Morrill
Vermont court rules on timber harvest dispute case









